EDUCATION: TEACHERS' SUPERANNUATION FUND.

Appendix to the Journals of the House of Representatives, 1911 Session I, E-09

E.—9

1911. NEW ZEALAND.

EDUCATION: TEACHERS' SUPERANNUATION FUND.

Laid before Parliament in pursuance of the Act.

CONTENTS. Page Pabt 1. Extract from report of Minister .. .. .. .. .. .. i 2. Report of Board, with additional statements to those prescribed by regulations .. 2 Statements prescribed by regulations .. .. .. .. .. .. 4

No. 1. EXTRACT FROM THE THIRTY-FOURTH ANNUAL REPORT OF THE MINISTER OF EDUCATION. The original Act, passed in 1905 and amended in certain respects in the following year, was repealed on the 10th October, 1908, by the Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908 (Part I), but existing contributors were allowed the option of electing to remain subject to the provisions of the original Act. The 30th June, 1910, was fixed as the date up to which such election might be made. The chief difference between the Act of 1908 and the former Acts affected the basis of calculation of the retiring-allowance of a contributor. The retiring-allowance was to be one-sixtieth of the average rate of salary received during the three years next preceding retirement, for each year of service, provided that in no case may the allowance exceed two-thirds of that salary : under the former Acts the basis had been one-sixtieth of the total salary received by the contributor during the period of contributing to the fund (or, in other words, one-sixtieth of his average salary for each year of service during the whole period of contribution), and, in addition, in the case of original members, one one-hundred-and-twentieth of the salary during the years of service between Ist January, 1878, and Ist January, 1906, with a further proviso that in no case should an original member receive a retiringallowance of less than £52 per annum. By the same Act of 1908 the right of persons employed on Ist January, 1906, as teachers in public schools or under the Education Department to be admitted at a future date was taken away. The Act of 1908 was amended in the following year by fixing a maximum retiring-allowance of £300 per annum in the case of persons who become contributors to the fund after the passing of the Act (24th December, 1909). Preparations are being made to enable the Actuary appointed by the Governor, in terms of the provisions of section 38 of the Act of 1908, to make the first examination of the fund. The examination will cover the period from the commencement of the fund on the Ist January, 1906, to the 31st December, 1910 —five years. Subsequent examinations will be made triennially. The Actuary's report will be duly printed, laid before Parliament, and copies distributed to contributors. At the end of 1910, The number of contributors was .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 3,247 Of whom members under Part IX of Education Act, 1908, number .. .. .. 128 The annual rate of contribution paid as at the end of the year was over .. .. £37,300

I—E. 9.

E.- 9

The number of retiring-allowances in Eorce at the end of the year was 270, representing an annual charge of over £14,261. Of these, Ordinary allowances were . . . . . . .. . . 158, representing £11,437 Allowances in medically unfit cases .. . . .. .. 21, .. 1,408 Allowances to widows .. .. .. . . .. 17. .. 611 Allowances to children . . . . .. . . .. 44, ~ 805 The balance at the credit of the fund and invested by the Public Trustee at the end of the year was . . . . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. £152,149 The average rate of inteiest earned by the investments at the end of the year was 4-Wi per cent.

No. 2. FIFTH REPORT OF THE BOARD CONSTITUTED BY THE PUBLIC SERVICE CLASSIFK A TION AND SUPERANNUATION AMENDMENT ACT (PART I), 1908. For the Year ending 31st December, 1910. The Honourable the Minister of Education. Sir,— Wellington, 18th April, 1911. The Board has to submit the following report for the year ending 31st December, 1910. The number of contributors increased from 3,152 at the end of 1909 to 3,247 at the end of 1910, and the number of persons in receipt of benefits increased during the year from 215 to 270. In terms of section 12 of the Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908, as amended in 1909,fthe Board, with the approval of the Minister of Education, adopted a set of terms and conditions payments into the fund by those contributors entitled to the benefits of[the extended provisionsjof that section. Details of the members of the fund on 31s1 December, 1910, grouped according to their statue, are given in the following tables : —

A. Statement of Membership as from 1st January, 1906.

♦Includes 2,252 transferred to Part I, Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908, and included in column (5) of the same line. t It was not until 1910 that it was ascertained that tnese five persons should have become niembers of the fund in terms of the provisions of section aof the Teachers' Superannuation .\ct, 1905. They are also included in columns (3) and (5) of the same line.

B. Total Number of Contributors who have joined and left the Fund since its Establishment (1st January, 1906, to 31st December, 1910).

2

Original Members. Original Members. Ordinary Members. Total Number at End of Period. Name of Act. (1.) A( Number Admitted. Left. at End of Period. (2.) (8.) (4.) 2,720 127 2,593 Number Ldrnittea. Left. at End of Period. (2.) (8.) (4.) r Number >f Admitted. Left. at End of Period. (">.) (6.) (7.) Number. Period. (8.) (9.) Teachers' Superannuation Act, 1905, and Amendment Act, 1901', Ditto 2,720 127 2,593 50 338 2,505 i 219 .. 219 197 89 877 2,812 Fifteen Months ending 31st March, 1907. 2,882 Year ending Hist March, 1908. 50 138 2,505 l'avt IX, Education Act, 1908. Part I of Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1!X)8. i Nnmhflv T° tal Number at End i NumDer. o f Period. 4 2,845* 164 ■2,409 ' 19 2,767 2,931 Nine Months ending 31et December, 1908. •20 144 .SHI 93 3.008 3,162 Year ending 31st December, 1909. 5f 21 128 282 1.71 8,119 3,247 Year ending 31st December, 1910. _j

Number. Annual Annual Rate M. V. Total. Salary ' Contributions. £ £ a. a. 'otal entered (including increases in salary 1,792 2,176 3,968 678,276 46,764 0 0 and contributions) 'otal discontinued (including reductions in 298 423 721 ' 130,344 9,479 0 0 salary and contributions) Total existing at 31st December, 1910 1,494 1,753 3,247 547,932 i 37,285 0 0

3

E.—9

C. Statement of Contributors on the Register as at 31st December, 1910, grouped according to Rate of Contribution per Cent, of Salary.

From rho above statements it will be found that there was a net increase of membership of 95 during the year 1910. Those members who have elected to remain subject to the provisions of Part IX of the Education Act, 1908, are probably persons whose service or salary would not insure a retiringallowaiioe exceeding the minimum allowance of £52 per annum provided for under that Act, and who otherwise desire to secure those benefits which it provides.

D. Progkkssivk Annual Table of Receipts and Expenditure (Ist January, 1906, to 3lst December, 1910). The following table shows the progress of the fund since its establishment : —

E. A Statement of Members of the Fund who at the end of 1910 had attained the Ages as shown therein.

Contribution per Cent. of Salary (Date when First Contribution became payable). Members uuder Part IX of the Education Act, 1908. Members under the Provisions of Part I of the Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908. Total. M. F. Total. 1 M. P. Total. M. F. Total. I M. F. Total. 5 6 7 8 9 10 5 6 7 8 9 10 9 6 15 5 9 14 10 18 28 6 -20 26 14 9 23 19 3 22 9 6 15 5 9 14 10 18 28 6 20 26 14 9 23 19 3 22 558 1,000 1/558 194 264 458 212 224 486 193 119 312 132 65 197 142 16 158 567 1,006 1,573 199 273 472 222 242 464 199 139 338 146 74 220 161 J 9 180 Totals . 63 65 128 1,431 1,688 3,119 1,494 1,753 3,247

I Total Num- Total Contributions ber of Con- (including Total Interest Period ended. tributors at Government received End of Grant) received during Period, Period. during Year. Total Income. Total Expenditure. £ s. ii. £ s. ( 31st March, 1907... 2,812 37,446 3 6! 863 15 31st March, 1908... 2,882 32,688 14 6 2,128 13 31st Dec, 1908 ... 2,931 27,153 10 6 1 2,373 10 31st Dec, 1909 ... 3,152 12,12111 1 4,751 9 31st Dec, 1910 ... 3,247 43,989 9 9 6,256 15 Totals ... ... 183,399 9 4 16,374 3 7 1 2 7 0 5 £ s. 38,309 19 34,817 7 29,527 0 46,873 0 50,246 1 199,773 12 Balance, £1. a. 1 7 s 8 9 9 L54 £ 8. d. 3,576 2 11 7,328 12 9 7,278 4 7 10,935 10 2 16,315 17 6 45,434 7 11 4,339 4s. 10d. 199,773 12 9 45,434 7 11 Balance, £154,339 4s. 10d.

Male. Number. Female. Age: Years. Age : Years. Number. 15-66 16-67 17-68 18-69 19-70 '0 8 1 1 1 55-56 56-57 57-58 58-59 59-60 60 •.. i 3 L a i 5 4 Totals... - 11 11 19

B.— 9

APPENDIX. 1. Statement of Contributors, showing Annual Rates of Salaries and Contributions as at 31st December, 1910.

Number. £ a. d. Of the number of contributors who retired during the year (including 6 medically unfit cases) retiring allowances were granted to .. .. .. 52 The annual rate of these allowances amounted to .. .. .. .. 5,372 10 0 The number of contributors who died, and on account of whom allowances or refunds of contributions were granted was .. .. .. .. 5 To the representatives of such contributors annual allowances granted (in two cases refunds of contributions were also made, and in the third case the contributions were commuted an annual allowance) to .. .. .. .. 3 widows and 4 children The annual rate of the allowances amounted to . . . . . . .. 113 19 0 The refunds of contributions .. .. . . .. .. .. 280 17 4 The total number of retired contributors on account of whom annual allowances were granted during the year was therefore .. .. .. 57 The remaining number of contributors who died was .. .. .. 4 On whose account contributions were refunded to their legal representatives to the amount of .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 375 12 10 The number of contributors who voluntarily retired from the Education service before becoming entitled to participate in the benefits of the fund and to whom refunds of contributions were made was .. .. .. 131 The refunds amounted to .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 2,862 11 3 The total number of contributors who retired from the Education service during — the year 1910 was .. .. .. .. .. .. 192

2. Particulars of Contributions discontinued during the Year ending 31st December, 1910.

Ten pensioners and two widows of deceased annuitants died during the year ; two children having attained the age of fourteen years theirallowance consequently ceased ; five widows and five children under fourteen years of age were granted annual allowances. Further details are given in the following table :

4

Number. Annual Rate of Annual Bate of Contributions Salary as at End of as at End of Year. Year. M. F. M. F. J Total. Contributors at 31st December, 1909 ... 1,473 1,679 New contributors entered during the 84 203 year ending 31st December, 1910 Increase in salaries and contributions by promotions during the year I 3,152 287 £ s. d. £ s. d511,240 0 0 35,544 0 0 35,734 0 0 1,862 0 0 36,466 0 0 2,416 0 0 Totals ... ... ... 1,557 1,882 Contributions discontinued during the | 63 129 year ending 31sc December, 1910, by resignation, &c. Decrease in salaries and contributions during the year 3,439 ■ 583,440 3,439 L92 31,314 192 0 0 0 39,822 0 0 0 2,087 0 0 4,194 0 0 450 0 0 i i Totals at 31st December, 1910 1,494 1,753 3,247 547,932 0 0 37,285 0 0

How discontinued. Number of Contributors. M. F. 3 fi Annual I Relate at Date of irement. —, £g Allowances granted. '5 I Salary. Contributions, >y death before pension entered £ £ B, d. £ s. d. £ s. d. upon— Contributions paid to personal representatives Leaving widow or child !y voluntary retirement Iedically unfit— Over fifteen years' service ... iy retirement at pension age ... 1 3 4 4 15 24 107 131 4 2 6 30 16 46 1 3 4 1 24 107 4 5 131 1,050 1,225 17,509 71 15 0 103 0 0 786 0 0 375 12 10 113 19 0 280 17 4 2,862 11 8 4 2 30 16 6 46 1,195 10,335 110 0 0 1,016 5 0 559 5 0 4,813 5 0 Totals 63 129 192 63 129 192 31,314 2,087 0 0 5,486 9 0 3,519 1 6

5

E.—9

3. Statement of Retiring-allowances (including Allowances to Widows and Children) for the Year ending 31st December, 1910.

(1-1 (2-) Total Retiring-allowances. Qn Attainment of Retirin g. age. Number. _. Number. J Annual Rate. Annual Rate. M. P. £ M. P. I (3.) Details of Column (2). Total 1 Particulars. Number. Medically unfit. V idows. Children. Nui iber. iber. Annual Rate. Nun M. P. Amount. Number. F. Number. M. j Annual Rate. M. P. I' i "I I Retiring-allowances as ac 31st December, 1909 96 119 Retiring-allowances granted during the year 36 23 at retirement of contributor Retiring-allowances granted to widows and 3 7 children of deceased annuitants . £ s. d. £ b. a. 96 119 215 9,538 12 0 72 i 48 7,316 7 S 36 23 59 5,486 9 0 30 16 4,813 5 0 9 £ s. d. 8 1,013 0 4 38 2 559 5 0 3 38 3 & B. d. 689 4 0 61 19 0 15 2 £ s. d. 25 520 0 0 2 52 0 0 3 7 10 155 0 0 5 5 90 0 0 3 2 65 0 0 : >j L : I I . Total 135 149 Retiring-allowances discontinued during 9 5 year* Retiring-allowances existing at end of year 126 144 1910 284 15,180 1 14 918 16 0 9 102 64 12,129 12 7 1 693 1 102 64 12,129 12 8 13 10 1,572 5 4 7 1 693 1 5 2 ... 163 15 4 8 5 10 1,572 5 4 ... 163 15 4 46 2 46 2 841 36 3 0 0 20 0 ... 29 637 0 0 2 26 0 0 : . _ 270 14,261 4 3 95 63 11,436 11 3 11 10 1,408 10 0 44 805 3 0 20 27 611 0 0 j I I * Particulars of Retiring■allowances discontinued during the Year. I How discontinued — By death By expiry ... Total 9 ... 9 " 3 12 : 892 16 9 2 2 26 0 0 5 14 918 16 9 7 1 693 15 2 ... 163 15 4 2 36 2 26 0 0 5 14 ! 918 16 9 7 1 693 1 5 2 ... 163 15 4 ; 918 16 9 i 1 693 1 5 2 ... 163 15 4 2 36 36 2 26 0 0 K. *j\j Progress o of Retiring-allowances since Establishment of Fund to 31st December, 1910. if Retiring-allowances sint i 158 311 16,280 12 3 113 64 12,754 6 1 18 11 1,913 3 2 14 41 : 2,019 8 0 | 18 1 1,317 14 10 7 1 504 13 2 47 3 859 54 3 0 0 0 Total granted ... Total discontinued ... J153 1 ... ! 27 158 311 16,280 12 3 14 41 i 2,019 8 0 ■22 2 36 754 0 0 9 143 0 0 I Total existing ... 126 1 144 270 144 270 14,261 4 3 14,261 4 3 95 63 111,436 11 3 I 11 I 10 1,408 10 0 44 : 805 3 0 20 I 27 611 0 0

E.—9

1. Further Details of Allowances. (a.) Return of Retiring-allowances discontinued during the Year 1st January to 31st December, 1910, and Annual Rate of Allowances granted to the Widows and Children.

(b.) Return of Widows and Children during the Year 1st January to 31st December, 1910, who ceased to be entitled to Benefits.

(c.) Return of Persons in Receipt of Annual Allowances as at the End of December, 1910. (i.) Allowances granted to Contributors who reached the Retiring-age.

6

Annuitant. Date from which rr Annual Kate of Retiring-allowance dis- n f , , diaoonZaod. R H . La Pf d continued and Payment o^™^. Retiring-allowances, of Benefits to Widow «"""«»»* and Children began. '■ 1. Foster, William E. ... 2. Goodwin, John S. 3. Hutcon, David C. 4. Jack, Bethia Miss 5. Macbeth, James J. 6. Marshall, Leslie C. :: ... 7. Peterson, William 8. Plunket-Cole, William 9. Scholes, Abraham 0. Warren, Francis* £ s. d. & s. fl. Death ... 64 18 0 7 March, 1910 ... 101 10 0 5 October, 1910 207 4 5 20 October, 1910 71 17 0 24 November, 1910 52 0 0 24 October, 1910 52 0 0 12 November, 1910 52 0 0 3 November, 1910 91 12 0 12 August, 1910 ... 22 I II 52 0 0 10 July, 1910 ... Ill 15 I 23 March, 1910 ... Totals ... 856 16 9 ... 22 4 11 22 4 LI ■■ Retired on grounds of medical unfitness.

xj Widow or Name. Chi]d Annual Rate of Dat ° °< *ermto«Uoii Allowance. of of Allowance. Hemarks. . 1. .Broughton, Janet, E. M. Child '2. Rowe, Daisy R. ... „ 8. Rowe, Jemima, Mrs. ... Widow... 4. Webber, Mary E., Mrs. £ 13 January, 1910i... 13 December, l<110 L8 July, 1910 18 October, 1910 ... Attained 14 years of age. Deceased. Total 6i2 6i2

Name. Occupation. Aot under whioh Annual Bate of Aliowanoe granted. Allowance. K, Education Act, 1908. A, Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908. Males. 1. Amoore, Albert H.* 2 Bannerinan, William ... 3. Barton, James 4. Bedford, Bernard S. .. 5. Bissell, Edward 6. Blair, James* 7. Bolton, Edwin C* 8. Bonnin, John L. 9. Boyd, Donald 10. Browne, Alfred A. 11. Bryant, James T.* 12. Budd, George W. E. ... 13. Bullock, Samuel 14. Burns, Andrew* 15. Butcher, Anthony G. ... 16. Comerford, William H. 17. Culverhouse, George* ... 18. Dale, Joseph ... 19. Daly, Michael F. : Teacher, Taranaki Education Board Otago Education Board Auckland Education Board „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... Nelson College „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Otago Education Board Truant Officer, Southland Education Board Assistant Truant Officer, Wanganui Education Board Teacher, Otago Education Board North Canterbury Education Board £ s. d. 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 72 3 0 ! 52 0 0 52 0 0 58 I 1 .) 9 115 17 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 63 11 0 124 6 0' 52 0 0 81 7 0 B B B l. B E B B B i-: A E B E B A A B A „ Native School... „ Taranaki Education Board Native School... North Canterbury Education Board Janitor, Timaru High School Board Teacher, Auckland Education Board * Allow; mces granted during the period from 1st January to 31st December, 1910.

X.—9.

(c.) Return of Persons in Receipt of Annual Allowances —continued. (i.) Allowances granted to Contributors who reached the Retiring-age— continued.

7

Name. Oooupation. Males— continued. 20. Duncan, William ... Teacher. Southland Education Board 21. Dunnett, Andrew ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 22. Dyer, Henry H. ... „ Wellington Education Board 23. Dyer, Robert C. ... „ Auckland Education Board 24. Easther, Henry A. ... Truant Inspector, Wanganui Education Board 25. Everiss, George ... Teacher. Marlborough Education Board 26. Ferguson, William ... „ Otago Education Board 27. Field, John L. ... „ Southland Education Board 28. Fitzgerald, William S.... inspector, Otago Education Board 29. Gates, Thomas A.* ... Teacher, North Canterbury Education Board 30. Gerring, Albert ... „ Auckland Education Board 31. Gillman, Alfred I. ... North Canterbury Education Board 32. Glenny, Joseph ... „ Auckland Education Board 33. Goulding, Richard ... „ FTawke's Bay Education Board ... 34. Gover, Frederick ... „ Wellington Education Board 35. Grant, James ... „ Taranaki Education Board 36 Greaves, Joseph ... „ South Canterbury Education Board 37. Gribble, Charles ... „ Auckland Education Board 38. Hardy, Charles J. ... „ Wellington Education Board 39. Hassing, George M. ... „ Southland Education Board 40. Horan, Thomas ... „ Native School 41. Horne, James* ... „ Wellington Education Board 42. Howard, Charles C. ... „ Marlborough Education Board ... --43. Hughson, William Janitor, Otago Eigh School Board 44. Ingpen, Edward L. ... Teacher. Wanganui Education Board 45. Johnston, Robert ... „ Wellington Education Board 46. Jones, Thomas A. ... „ Auckland Education Board 47. Kilburn, Joseph ... „ Southland Education Board 48. La Prelle, John J.* „ Auckland Education Board 49. Lee, Wesley ... ... „ „ 50. Lock, Charles H. W.* ... Wanganui Education Board 51. Lothian, John, Rev. ... ,. Auckland Education Board 52. Lyttle, John ... ... ., Southland Education Board ... 53. Macan, George H. ... „ „ 54. McDonald, Kenneth ... „ 55. McFarlane, Henry* ... „ Wellington Education Board 56. McFarlane, Peter G. M. „ North Canterbury Education Board 57. Mclntoeh, Alexander ... „ Auckland Education Board 58. McNicoll, David A.* ... „ Otago Education Board 59. Maddison, John ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 60. Matthews, Ernest W. I). „ Native school 61. Menzies, George ... „ Otago Education Board 62. Milne, William 63. Moore, William J.* ... 64. Moores, Peter ... „ Auckland Education Board 65. Morgan, Richard ... „ Taranaki Education Board 66. Mulhern, John ... „ Native school 67. Murdoch, James ... „ Southland Education Board 68. Murray, David* ... „ Otago Education Boawl 69. Murray, George \Y. ... „ Auckland Education Board 70. Nicholls, Alfred ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 71. Orr, James" ... ... „ Southland Education Board 72. O'Shea, Jeremiah ... „ Xelson Education Board 73. Petrie, Donald ... Inspector, Auckland Education Board 74. Plunket-Cole, W.*t ... Teacher, Wellington Education Board 75. Pole, Richard P.* ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 76. Porritt, Thomas, Rev. ... „ Wellington Education Board 77. Reid, James ... ... „ Otago Education Board 78. Rice, Vincent E. : ... Secretary, Auckland Education Board • 79. Schmidt, Peter E. ... Architect to North Canterbury Education Board Act under whioh Annual Rate of| AUowanoe 8 ranted - Allowance. IB, Education Act, 1908. A, Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908. I £ b. d. 52 0 0 : E 120 6 0 A 52 0 0 K 52 0 0 B 94 II 0 A 52 0 0 l^ ... 52 0 0 B 52 0 0 B 251 7 0 A 147 16 0 A 52 0 0 K 52 0 0 E 52 0 0 B 118 0 0 A 52 0 0 E 52 0 0 E 106 0 0 A 52 0 0 E 77 15 4 E 52 0 0 E 52 0 0 E 233 8 0 A 68 8 2 E 52 0 0 E 52 0 0 E 52 0 Oj E ... ! 52 0 0 E ... -52 0 0 E 52 0 0 E 52 0 0i E 156 11 01 A 52 o o; e 52 0 0 E 75 13 i A 52 0 0j E 79 18 0 A 52 0 0 E 62 10 0 A 188 10 0 A 52 0 0 1 E 52 0 0j E 52 0 0 E 85 4 5 ! E 148 19 0 A 52 0 0 ! E 62 1 0 A 52 0 0 E 52 0 0 E 172 11 0 A 129 7 0 A 56 5 9| E 126 12 0 A 52 0 0 E 325 17 0 A 91 12 0j A 52 0 0i B 52 0 0 E 89 0 11 ; E 319 7 0 A 52 0 0 1 E • Allowances granted duiing the period from 1st January to 31st December, 1910. f Deceased, 12th August, 1910.

E.—9

8

(c.) Return of Persons in Receipt of Animal Allowances— continued. (i.) Allowances granted to Contributors who reached the Retiring-age— continued.

Name. Occupation. TCaTc" " Name. Act under which Annual Rate o( Allowance Allowance. E Amendment Aot. 1908. Males —continued. £ 8 . a, 80. Scott, James ... ... Teacher, South Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 81._Scott, Samuel M/ : ... „ Nelson Education Board ... ... 69 12 0 82.'3;Sloman, John P. ... j „ Auckland Grammar School Board ... 87 8 6 83.JSmall, James S ... Truant Officer, Auckland Education Board ... 58 19 0 84. Smith, John ... .. Secretary to Marlborough High School, and Secretary 78 19 10 Marlborough Education Board 85. Stenhouse, John ... Teacher, Otago Education Board ... ... 230 2 0 86. Stevens, Joseph E.* ■ „ ... . 118 5 0 87. Stewart, Alexander ... „ „ ... ... 88 6 0 88. Stewart, James" ... „ North Canterbury Education Board ... 69 0 0 89. Stewart, "Washington S. „ Wanganui Education Board ... ... 55 9 8j 90. Stott, Alexander ... „ Southland Education Board ... ... 93 11 0 91. Taylor, William N. ... ! „ North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 92. Tobin, William H. J. ... ' „ Native School... " ... ... ... 52 0 0; 93. Ward, Joseph ... „ Marlborough Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 94. Ward, William South Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 95. Wood, John*.. „ ... 138 16 0 96. Young, Henry ... „ Native school... ... ... ... 52 0 0 Total ... ... ... 7,800 3 5 Females. 1. Anderson, Barbara C. ... Teacher, Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 2. Anderson, Elizabeth, Mis. „ Native school... ... ... ... 52 0 0| 3. Barton, Annie, Mrs. ... „ Auckland Education Board ... 52 0 0j 4. Batten, Annie E. B Westland Education Board ,.. ... 52 0 0j 5. Beale, Arundel M. ... j „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 6. Beattie, Jane, Mrs. ... „ Native school... ... ... ... 52 0 0 7. Blades, Bithiah ... „ Auckland Grammar School ... ... 71 7 9 8. Blyth, Sarah F. E. ... „ Wanganui Education Board ... 52 0 0 9. Brown, Jessie C* ... „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... ... 108 6 0 10. Bullock, Julia W. ... North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 11. Caldwell, Margaret* ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 77 10 0 12. Carrick, Marie* ... „ Otago Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 13. Christie, Catherine W. „ Native school... ... ... ... | 52 0 0 14. Coleman, Annie E.* .. „ Nelson Education Board ... ... 31 0 0 15. Cowens, Janet * ... „ North Canterbury Education Board ... 74 15 0 16. Dement, Mary A. ... „ Nelson Education Board ... ... 52 0 0, 17. Dunning, Eliza L. „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 18. Evans, Alice*... „ Taranaki Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 19. Forsyth, Agnes* ... „ Otago Education Board ... ... 63 11 0 20. Francis, Catherine A. ... „ Wellington Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 21. Goulding, Jane E. ... . Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 22. Gower, Nanette* ... „ Wellington Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 23. Greensill, Susan M. C Native school... ... ... 52 0 0 24. Haig, Catherine ... „ Otago Education Board ... ... 104 3 4 25. Hall, Mary* ... ... „ North Canterbury Education Board ... 115 2 0 26. Haughton, Sophia E. .1. „ „ ... ... 52 0 0 27. Haultain, Frances A. ... „ Native school... ... ... ... 52 0 0 28. Heney, Annie ... „ Auckland Educatidn Board ... ... 52 0 0 29. Henry, Margaret „ ... ... 52 0 O^ 30. Hoey, Jemima N. ... „ Wanganui Education Board ... ... 52 0 0| 81. Hopper, Mary E. ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 80 18 0, 32. Huie, Marjory S. ... Otago Education Board ... ... 56 19 9; 33. Hyatt, Alice S. ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0! 34. Jack, Bethia*t „ ... ... 7117 0i 35. Johnson, Susan H. ... „ Native school... ... ... ... 52 0 0 , 36. Jordan, Mary E.* ... „ Wellington Education Board ... ... 108 1 0 37. Kitchingman, Eliza ... North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 38. Lissaman, Martha H. ... Hawke's Bay Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 39. Longmore, Frances ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 40. McGavin, Jessie ... „ Native school... ... ... ... 52 0 0 E A E A B A A ! E A E E E B A E E i E A E A B A E E A A 3 E A E E E E A A E E E E ! A E A E A E E E E • Allowances granted during the period from 1st January to 31st December, 1910. t Deceased 24th No' rember, 1910.

E.—9

(c.) Return of Persons in Receipt of Animal Allowances —continued. (i.) Allowances granted to Contributors who reached the Retiring-age— continued.

2 E. 9.

9

Act under which A low ;i •]<:<• granted. Name. Occupation. Annual Bate Klllu . aUol , A ct,i908. of Allowance. A _ Superannuation Amendment Aot, IHO.-i Females —continued. ■ £ s. d. 41. Mackay, Ida O. Teacher, Westland Education Board ... ... 52 0 01 li 42. Metherell, Rosa M.* ... ., North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 Oi E 43. Moller, Louisa A. ... Nelson Education Board ... ... 52 0 0J E 44. Nicholson, Maud* ... „ Auckland Kducation Board ... ... 81 10 0 A 45. Paterson, Jane ... „ Otago Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 E 46. Peake, Sarah N. ... „ Marlborough Education Board ... ... j 52 0 0 E 47. Pettit, Barbara M.* ... „ Nelson Education Board ... ... | 66 15 0 A 48. Phillips, Mary ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... | 02 0 0 E 49. Plummer, Mary ... „ „ ... ... 52 0 U E 50. Ritchie, Christian ... ., South Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 E 51. Simpson, Margaret E. ... „ North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 K 52. Sinclair, Elizabeth* ... , Auckland Education Board ... ... 92 15 0 A 53. Stevens, Dora S. ... „ Otago Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 E 54. Stewart, Jessie ... „ Industrial school ... ... ... 52 0 0 E 55. Taylor, Mary ... . North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 E 56. Tennent, Margaret I. ... „ Native school ... ... ... ... ! 52 0 0 l< , , 57. Tregear, Mary G. ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 K 58. Wakelin, Ellen A. ... Cookery Instructress, Wellington Education Board... 52 0 0 lj 59. Will, Louisa M. ... Teacher, Otago Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 E 60. Williams, Alice L.* „ Taranaki Education Board ... 80 10 0 A 61. Wilson, Jane... .. „ Otago Education Board ... ... 70 16 0 A 62. Wimperis, Frances M. ... , Otago Girls'High School ... ... 52 0 0 E 63. Woodward, Laura „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 B 64. Wraytt, Christina „ Southland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 E Total ... ... ... J£3,799 16 10 160 Grand total ... ... £11,600 0 3 * Allowances granted during the period from 1st January to 31st Dacember, 1910. (it.) Allowances granted to Contributors medically unfit for Further Duty. Act under winch I Allowance granttd. Name. Occupation. i ofAllowance E, Kducatiot. Act.isoe. OI Allowance. A supraannuatiOD Amend luentAot. I I Wβ. Males. £ g. d. 1. Baragwanath, John ... Teacher, South Canterbury Education Board .. 52 0 0 E 2. Bussell, Henry ... „ North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 15 3. Dalby, John H. ... . , . 52 0 0 E 4. Feist", Adolph M. ... „ Wellington Education Board ... ... 98 2 0 A 5. Harrison, Thomas C. „ Otago Education Board ... ... ... 52 0 0 E 6. Hogwood, James* ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 163 7 0 A 7. Kerr, Charles K* ... „ Otago Education Board ... ... ... 97 15 0 A 8. McGlure, William D/' „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... ... 90 9 0 A 9. Marr, Thomas M. ... „ North Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 E 10. Mason, Herbert ... „ Auckland Education Board ... 75 3 0 A 11. Rice, John H.* ... , Taranaki Education Board ... ... 92 2 0 A Females. 1. Albert, Sarah E. ... Teacher, Otago High Bchool Board ... ... 52 0 0 K 1. Boulcott, Henrietta... , Wellington Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 E 3. Ecclesfield, Isabel* ... „ Wellington Girls'College... ... ... 63 12 0 A 4. Lea, Mary E.* Southland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 • E 6. McKay, Elizabeth* . „ Otago Education Board ... ... ... 52 0 0 E 6. Ostners, Mary E. ... „ Westland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 E 7. Paul, Susan B. ... „ Otago Education Board ... ... ... 52 0 0 E 8. Peat, Janet H. .. „ Wanganui Education Board ... ... 5'2 0 0 B 9. Bay, Josephine „ Auckland Education Board ... ... 52 0 0 E 10. Rowley, Jane G. ... „ South Canterbury Education Board ... 52 0 0 B 21 Total ... ... ... ... £1,408 10 0 £1,408 10 0 * Allowances granted during the period l«t January to 3lst December, I'.iJO. * ■, 1910.

E.—9.

(iii.) Allowances granted to Widows of Deceased Contributors.

• Allowances granted during period from Ist January to 31st December, 1910.

10

Act under which Allowance granted. Widows. Occupation of Deceased Contributor. Annual Bate of Allowance. K, Education Act, 190H. A, Superannuation Amendment Act, 1 I90& 1. Adams, Annie, Mrs. 2. Baldwin, Mary A., Mrs. Teacher, Thames High School Board „ North Canterbury Education Hoard i I * s. d. 18 0 0 18 0 0 i ie o o I 5 4 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 i<: 3. Bennett, Mary R., Mrs. „ Otago Education Board B I 4. Berry, Alice M., Mrs. ... 5. Bramley. Charlotte, Mrs. 6. Broughton, Esther, Mrs. 7. Brownlee, Lilian G., Mrs. 8. Closs, Jane, Mrs. 9. Crummy, Sarah, Mrs. ... 10. Dawson, Annie, Mrs. ... 11. Duthie, Grace. Mrs. 12. Ellis, Elizabeth, Mrs. ... 13. Evans, Margaret A. T., Mrs. 14. Fannin, Martha, Mrs. ... 15. Ferguson,Elizabeth,Mrs. 16. Foster, Frances, Mrs.*... 17. Gloy, Margaret, Mrs. ... 18. Golding, Mary R., Mrs... 19. Goodwin, Zillah, Mrs.* 20. Greenwood, iMargaret, Mrs. 21. Hailey, Elizabeth, Mrs. 22. Hutchinson. Margaret Mrs. North Canterbury Education Board E E B \ Native school ... Marlborough Education Board „ Otago PJducation Bonn i Clerk to Board, Canterbury College Teacher, Wauganui Education Board „ Native school ... Secretary to Nelson Education Board Teacher, Taranaki Education .Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 E E E B E A „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ North Canterbury Education Board South Canterbury Education Board „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Otago Education Board inspector, Auckland Education Board Teacher, Native school ... 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 o 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 is 0 0 A E A E E B K Southland Education Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 i<: B 23. Ingpen, Emily B., Mrs. 24. Kerr. Catherine S., Mrs. 25. Ladley, Ada, Mrs.* 26. Lindsay, Lillias, Mrs. ... 27. Look, Bertha R, Mrs. 28. Maber, Grace M., Mrs.... 29. McClelland, Elizabeth.)., Mrs. 30. McKinnou, Grace, Mrs. 31. Malcolm, Janet. Mrs. • .■.. 32. Marshall, Eliza l< , .. Mrs. 33. Mason, Margaret H. It.. Mrs. 34. Neill, Susan, Mrs. 35. Patrick, Mary J., Mrs.... 36. Potts, Rosamond, Mrs.... 37. Selby, Emma. Mrs. 38. Sigley, Lillie ('.. Mrs. ... 39. Smith, Mary A., Mrs.*... 40. Tegner, Clara F., Mrs... 41. Walter, Rosa A., Mr-. ... 42. Warren, Ethel, Mis. 43. Watt, Elizabeth, Mrs. ... Hawke 6 Bay Education Board ... „ North Canterbm-y Rducation Board Marlborough Education Board Otago Education Board Wellington Education Board Hawke's Bay Education Board ... , Otago Education Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 !> 0 0 E E A E E B i<: Southland High School Board Hawke's Bay Education Board ... Otago Education Board ,, Wellington Education Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 i<: E i<; A Hawkes Bay Education Board ... Native school ... Taranaki Education B<i,uii Southland Education Board „ Native school ... Christchurch Boys' High School... „ Wanganui Education Board „ Native school ... Auckland Education Board ! 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 7 19 0 E i<: E i<: E A E E A i<: 44. Young, Mary A.. Mrs. , & „ Otago Education Board 1 E Total £805 H

11

E.—9

(iv.) Allowances granted to Children of Deceased Contributors and Annuitants

Act under whiob Allowance granted. N;une. Oooupacion of Deceased Oontribator. nlTlVnwnifno E, Education Act, 1906. 01 Aliowanoe. A superannuation Amendment Act, 1908. I Males. t 1. Bramley, Clifford E. ... ! Teacher, North Canterbury Education Board ... 13 B 2. J3rownlee, John K. ... t „ Marlborough Education Board ... ... 13 A 3. Glarkson, Bernard T. ... j „ Wanganui Education Board ... ... 13 E 4. Dale, John H* ... „ Native school ... ... ... ... l>1 A 5. Evans, Eoss ... „ Taranaki Education Board ... ... L8 A 6. Evans, James L. ... „ „ ... ... 13 A 7. Evans, William S . ... ... L3 A 8. Evans, Harry M. ... „ „ ... ... I:; A 9. Evans, Colin M. „ ... ... 13 A tO. Evans, Jack ... „ ... 18 \ U. Greenwood, Milton ... | „ Native school ... ... ... 18 E 12. Look, William J.* ... „ Wellington Education Board ... ... L3 E 13. McKinnon. Hugli L Southland High School Board ... IH E 14. McKinnon, John C. ... „ „ ... ... 18 E 15. Sigley, Edgar ... „ Native school ... ... ... .. 13 E 16. Sigley, Harry S. ... | „ „ .. ... ... ... 13 B 17. Smith Edward H.* ... | „ Christchurch Boys' High School ... ... 13 A 18. Warren, Francis M.* ... , Auckland Education Board ... 18 A 19. Warren, Horace V.* .... „ ... ...18 A 20. Watt, Alan M. ... Architect to Auckland Education Board ... .. i 13 E Females. 1. Bennett, Dorothy V. ... Teacher, Otago Education Board ... ... ; L3 B 2. Berry, Dorothy M. ... „ North Canterbury Education Board .-., 13 E 3. Bramley, Gladys V „ ... ... ! 1.3 E 4. Bramley, Daisy E. ... „ ... 13 B 5. Bramley, Winifred M . ...... 13 E 6. Broughton, Esther P.N. „ Native school ... ... ... ... 13 E 7. Broughton, Helen S. R. j „ „ ... ... ... ... 13 B 8. Brownlee, Gwendolen A. „ Marlborough Education Board ... ... 13 \ 9. Clarkson. Marv L. ... , Wanganui Education Board ... ... 18 E 10. Clarkson, Este'lla G „ ... ... | ' 13 B 11. Evans, Madge M. ... „ Taranaki Education Board ... ... j 18 A 12. Gloy, Olga H. M. ... „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... ... L8 E 13. Hutchinson, Margaret „ Southland Education Board ... ... L3 E M. N. 14. Hutchineon. Kathleen „ „ ... ... 13 K M. B. 15. Look, Gwendoline* ... „ Wellington Education Board ... ... 13 E 16. Look, Eeoni ... „ „ ...... j 13 E 17. Maber, Kathleen E. ... „ Hawke's Bay Education Board .. ... 13 E 18. Marshall, Zealanda ... ., Otago Education Board... ... ... 13 H 19. Marshall, Eliza F. S , „ .. ... 13 E 20. Potts, Lilian J. ... „ Taranaki Education Board . .. 18 E 21. Sigley, Hattie E. ... „ Native school ... ... ... ... , 13 E 22. Sigley, Joyce C. ... „ „ ... ... ... .. 13 E 23. Sigley, Hazel M „ ... ... ... ... 13 E 24. Sigley, Ethel G. ... , „ L3 E 25. Warren, Lila ;: ... „ Auckland Education Board ... ... L3 A 26. Warren, Eva E.* , ... ... 13 A 27. Webber, Mina H. O. ... , Hawke's Bay Education Board ... ... 18 E 47 Total ... ... ... ... tfill i . ' i * Allowances granted during period from 1st January to 31*t Deoember, 1910.

E.—9

12

Tbichbrs' Superannuation Fund Year ending 31st December, 1910. Beventoe Account. & s. d. £ s. d. £ s. d To Balance 81st Deoember, 1909 .120,406 17 7 By AllowancesContributions .. .. .. 36,989 9 9 Paid .. .. 12,292 010 Government subsidy .. .. 7,000 0 0 Outstanding.. .. 127 8 4 Interest .. .. .. .. 6,256 15 0 12,419 9 2 Contributions refunded .. .. 3,653 18 11 Commission .. .. .. 369 17 9 Balanoe .. .. .. .. 154,211 16 6 £170,655 2 4 £170,655 2 4 Balance-sheet. £ s. d. £ s. d. Fund as per Revenue Account .. .. 154,211 16 6 In hands of Public Trustee for investment 152,149 0 2 Retiring-allowances in transit— Contributions in transit .. .. 526 0 4 £19 19 11 Interest acorued and outstanding to 127 8 4 31/12/10 .. .. .. .. 1,880 6 9 147 8 3 Commission aoorued to 31/12/10 .. 146 2 6 £154,505 7 3 £154,505 7 8 K. O. Gibbbs, Secretary for education. F. K. de (Jastbo, Chief Clerk and Aocountant, and Secretary to Teaohors' Superannuation Board. Examined and found correct.—B. J. Collins, Controller and Auditor General. The amount in the hands of the Public Trustee lor investment is £152,119 os. 21. CX obis sum £126,600 has been invested on mortgage : £79,350 at 5 par cent., £3,750 at 4f p;r ceit . and £43,500 at 4J per cent. The balanoe, £25,519 os. 2d., is awaiting investment. I have, &c, Geo. Fowlds, Chairman, Teachers' Superannuation Board.

AptrfftXM.tr Coat of Paper —Preparation, not yivun ; printing (5,000 oopies), 415 15s.

Authority : John Maokay, Government Printer, Wellington. 1911

Pries 6d.)