NORTH OTAGO

Otago Daily Times, Issue 22353, 29 August 1934, Page 12

NORTH OTAGO

ACTIVITIES OF THE DISTRICT

(FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT.)

ACRIMONIOUS DISCUSSION DISSENSION IN POWER BOARD DECENTRALISATION PROPOSAL The Finance Committee reported to the Waitaki Electric Power Board yesterday morning, that at. a special meeting of the committee held on-August 27, the chairman read'' an oSer from Mr A. Fyfe, Duntroon,. for his property, consisting of an up-to-date house and a threequarter acre section for £750. After consideration of the requirements, Mr MTMarmid moved, seconded by MrCrombie, that a , sub-committee consisting; of. Messrs Rutherford and Newlands, the}ehgineer and the chairman, inspect the property and also take Mr Steenson’s advice. The sub-committee reported that th 6 property was , a very, desirable one, the price was . reasonable, and recommended the purchase. - It was reported that;Mr Fyfe’s property. was ■ puchased by the board for V£7oo, and Mr Maindonald’s house at Duntroon, , for £425. _ o'-' When the matter- came up for discussion, Mr Milligan said that as the expiry date of the offer limited the time of the committee, every member of the board was consulted, either, personally or by telephone, and the majority was in favour of the purchase. Mr Lang said that the proposal to station two men at Duntroon was to be an experiment, Mr Forrester stating that there was a minute to that effect. Mr MTnnes asked the chairman when the board gave him authority to purchase the properties. Mr Milligan replied by interview ,or by telephone. They were not unanimous, but there was a majority. Mr MTnnes asked if there, had ever been a complaint or not providing service to consumers in any part of the district. Mr Milligan asked Mr MTnnes to resume his seat, as they could not discuss the question of stationing men at Duntroon. That had already been decided on by the board. Mr MTnnes said .Mr Milligan had never been authorised to purchase the' houses. He . had something to say on the matter, and Mr Milligan would hot block him.

Mr MTnnes was again asked«to resume his seat, and Mr Newlands, to give'Mr MTnnes an opportunity to speak, moved that the recommendation of the committee be the houses purchased, Mr Lang said that when Mr Milligan rang him up he was told that the subcommittee had gone out to look at the places, and was unanimously of the opinion that they were of good value. He. put the question that it was to be an experiment at ■Duntroon. However, if it had been agreed that the place be purchased at that money then he had no objection. He was vei-y strongly opposed to placing two men at Herbert. He certainly would/ not be in favour, of the purchase of the houses, unless a majority of the boards said the purchase was necessary. Mr Milligan .assented that Mr Lang’s statement was quite right. The very closest inquiry had been made, Mr MTnnes" said Mr Milligan carefully avoided to tell Mr Lang that he was against it. Mr MDiarmid said it was. only an experiment. Mr Milligan said what Mr Lang said wag quite right, but he said if the committee was in favour of purchase, and considered the price satisfactory, then he would agree. On the question of interpretation of the word experiment, while the principle extended to the country it was not an.- experiment so far as Duntroon was concerned, because a majority of the hoard was ,satisfied that it was going to he a success. Mr MTnnes: Question. Mr Milligan said he was sorry Mr MTnnes suggested he did not say Mr MTnnes had objected. He said.a majority of the board agreed, but there was no intention on hie part to hide the information thai-Mr'MTnuGS had not agreed. Mr Rutherford said that so far as he was concerned he only Wanted to see that the value wag there. He was told Mr MTnnes dissented, but was led to understand that Mr Forrester would agree. Mr’ Forrester said he was against it, and Mr MTnnes said it was going to be a dear experiment. Mr Rutherford’ said it might not be so dear. Mr Fyfe would not lease the house, and Mr Maindonald’s had to be sold. He rang up Mr Milligan and told him that the house was good value. Mr MTnnes. said it would cost £2OOO before it was finished.

Mr Rutherford ; said. they agreed thatmarried men would he sent to Duntroon, and they had to get houses. • Mr Milligan said that when Mr MTnnes objected to the purchase of any property he asked if they could lease, and Mr Fyfe stated he'would not’ lease. He had asked Mr Denford to ring up Mr Forrester and explain, the matter. Mr Denford said he had rung up Mr Forrester asking for his [viewpoint, and had stated that Mr Dalmer and Mr Steenson had approved of the purchase. Mr Forrester said he was glad he had spared his feelings, and said he would take no objection. • Mr Forrester said he went away to the-baek-hlocks to get away from this sort ’ of thing. He asked what was the use> of ringing him-up, as he supposed it was. all “cut and dried.” He said,-they, would never be able to sell the properties and would never get the money Mr Denford said he thought Mr Forresterrhad said, he 'would not object to the purchase. V. Mr Forrester replied that he would certainly be thoroughly inconsistent if be agreed to this sthpid move. Mr Milligaii said-rent would be charged and there was no reason why there should be , any charge on the board.- The board

would run a little risk, but it could not get suitable houses to rent, and the rent would meet the annual charges, and the scheme was going to be a success. Mr Newlands said that he was quite satisfied that when Mr Lang saw Duntroon being served by these two men. being, a reasonable man, he would, come round and let two men go to Otepopo. Mr MTnnes might not be reasonable, but how could they appoint men without houses. What was Mr MTnnes’s opinion of Mr Fyfe’s house and grounds? Mr MTnnes; Very good. Mr Newlands said Mr Steenson had stated that the value of the house and ground in town would be £IBOO. He pre•ferred to take the opinion of an expert to that of. a layman. Mr MTnnes interjected, and Mr Newlands retorted: You’re childish.

Mr MTnnes replied: You’re childish, and very childish. There is not a house there worth £IBOO.

■ Mr Milligan called the meeting to order. ■ Mr Meek said that although’ there was.no definite move for the purchase of houses at the last meeting, but after the inquiry by the committee, he thought they should stand by the recommendation. His reason, for so doing was that another public body was • placing married men in' good, homely conditions, where there was sufficient work to warrant their appointment. He doubted if two men would be able to cope with the work at Duntroon, but the board should make the conditions homely and comfortable. The board would collect rent as did the Waitaki. County Council, and he thought they were doing the right thing in giving the workers good conditions. Mr MTnnes said Mr Meek told him the house was dirt cheap. Mr Forrester said that was not the point. It was the principle. Mr Rutherford said the house was well worth the money, but did they go the right way about purchasing it? Mr Milligan said all the members were consulted.

Mr MTHamid said the board got a bargain. The majority decided that an experiment would be made at Duntroon, and they had to start under favourable conditions. Were they going to kill the experiment by making the conditions impossible? Mr MTnnes suggested getting a couple of huts from the Hydro, and then suggested boarding , the men. They would kill the experiment by creating conditions that were intolerable. They were going to make the experment a success, and they would start out under favourable conditions. Mr Forrester had characterised their action as “ cut and dried,”; and stupid. They should not be characterised as stupid. They had given the matter much thought, and had got a really good bargain. The majority of the board had decided to take this course of action.

Mr MTnnes said Mr Milligan did not have authority to purchase. He (Mr Milligan) had led the board astray when he said it was going to be in the interests of the board. He said it was going to be a huge success.-; Where did he get his information from? Mr Milligan ruled Mr MTnnfes out of order. He protested against Mr MTnnes saying he led the board astray. Mr M'Diarmid bad explained that it was necessary to purchase homes that, the men should be properly housed. The majority of the board had decided that, but it was competent for members to record their vote against it. Mr Forrester said he thought the whole thing irregular. The resolution of the board gave no authority to' purchase bouses. He asked how the house came to be offered.

Mr Milligan said Mr Forrester did not object to the consideration of the matter ■by the Finance Committee. Mr Forrester: I asked how the house came to be offered.

Mr Rutherford said Mr Fyfe came to him the Saturday after the last meeting. Mr Forrester said that was quite satisfactory if it came that way. I- Mr Rutherford stated that he asked Fyfe how the board came to know, but Mr Fyfe did not answer, and be took it to be he was keeping ; t from his brother. ■> O i " \

Mr Milligan said he met Mr Sumpter and asked him if-he knew of any in Duntroon. Mr Forrester said he was perfectly 1 satisfied that the chairman and members went outside their authority in doing what they had done. He was pleased to hear Mr Newlands say he would listen to an expert and not a layman. Did he do that in connection with ‘the experiment? Mr Newlands replied that Mr Dalmer had indicated it in his report in 1932. Mr Forrester said he was against a very considerable expenditure of £3OOO or £4OOO, which would mean more loan money. It was over the odds. The experiment did not mean the expenditure of £3OOO or even £2OOO. What about the motor ears?

Mr Milligan said Mr Dalmer had indicated a shortage of vehicles. [ Mr Forrester said they had sold the Other cars. He objected to the ho'e-and-corner business, and neither did he approve of ringing up. It was a rotten principle. Already matters to come beforo the committee were arranged between Mr M.illigan and his supporters. He hoped 'that in future all matters would be argued at the board table.

Mr M'Diarmid said nothing was suppressed, and Mr Crombie also denied Mr Forrester’s statement, i Mr Milligan said it was a thousand pities that personalities should be introduced. It was tiresome to the ratepayers and tiresome to the members of the board to have recriminations at the meetings. Was it not possible for them to meet as gentlemen and discuss these things, leaving out personalities? The purchase of the houses cost’ a. little over £llsO, without motor cars, which lere needed in any case, according to the engineer, All would be covered by rents, and cheap rents, too. The board did not stand to lose anything, by the deal. Matters were referred to the. committee from

time to time, and the committee exercised judgment whether members should be consulted. He assured Mr Forrester that there was no attempt to do hole-and-corner business, and that charge was disproved. In this case every member was consulted ,and the majority was in favour, and it was competent for members to vote against it. On the- other hand he felt sure a majority of the board would vote in confirmation of the recommendation. That would put the matter in order. There musfc be give and take, and when it is impossible to comply with the rule, if the majority favoured a proposal it could be confirmed at the meeting. On a show of hands that the recomdation be approved, Messrs Rutherford, Newlands. , M'Diannid, Meek, Milligan, and Crombic voted in favour of the proposal, and Messrs Forrester and MTnnes against it. Mr Lang did not record his vote. The questions of repairs to Mr Maindonald’s house, motor vehicles, and fixing of the rentals, were referred to the Finance Committee. The purchase of a hut from the Waitaki Hydro for a storeroom at Duntroon, was approved. Messrs West (electrician) and Meyrick (linesman) \vero appointed to the Duntroon depot. POWER BOARD STAFF REPORT SENT TO COMMITTEE The engineer (Mr I. Dalmer) submitted a lengthy report to the Waitaki Electric Power Board yesterday morning in reference to the complaint made as to the delay in the men leaving the depot in the morning., The report was not released for publication, and Mr Milligan’ suggested that it be referred to the Finance Committee for report to the’ next meeting. Mr Forrester said he was against delay in the matter. . Mr Meek stated that he had raised the question, but it was never in his mind that the men should leave the depot at 8 o’clock. They should arrive there at 8 o’clock, and get away as soon as pos* sible. Mr Lang: Is it not a pity that it went out to' the press from last without giving the men an opportunity of reply? . Mr Milligan said they were on the brink of another very full discussion, and he asked members to refer the report to the committee, and they could have a very full discussion at the next meeting. This was agreed to. Mr MTnnes said that a very serious charge had been made by Mr Freebury against Mr Sullivan. Mr Milligan said the matter had yet to be inquired into. It was a very per.sonal matter, and he assured members that it would not be burked. He would esteem it a courtesy if Mr MTnnes would let the matter stand over. It would be dealt with. Mr Forrester said he hoped it would be. The general surroundings were bad, and he hoped it would not be left in the air. The matter was held oyer pending an inquiry. GENERAL NEWS High Water at Oamaru.—August 29: 5.57 a.m. and 6.22 p.m. The Oamaru Municipal Band is holding its annual fancy drees dance in the Scottish Hall to-night, when a large crowd is expected. There will be four prizes worth 10s each, the judges for the costumes being Mrs -Clayforth and Mrs Bee. The orchestra engaged is the New Melodians, including Mr D. Hinds (vocalist), with Mr Ted. Heaney, of Dunedin, the piano-accordion player. Dancing commences at 8 p.m., and those attending will be assured of a excellent evening. The Pukeuri Welfare Club held a very successful euchre tournament and dance, the prizes for the former being won by Mr Taplin 1, Mrs G. Hunter 2, and Mr M. Hickey 3.

A very enjoyable gift evening was held in the Pukeuri Hall in honour of Miss Florence Craig and Mr James Plunket, who are shortly to be married. A euchre tournament was held, Miss G. Kirkwood and Mr Ingram 'being the winners, and consolation prizes going to Miss Padkin and Mr H. Valk. Mr W. Restall referred to the popularity of their guests, and Mrs S; Craig, on behalf of the Pukeuri Women’s Division, presented them with a chair. Mr Markham, on behalf of the Pukeuri Debating Society, presented them with a set of carvers, after which a large assortment _of presents from residents of the district was presented. Mr Plunket suitably acknowledged the presents. Dancing was indulged in to music supplied by Mr F. Mountford, an extra being played by Mr H. Valk. Mi- 6. Hunter carried out the duties of M.C. Mr R. Walker lias given notice of motion to the next meeting of the North Otago Provincial Executive of the Farmers’ Union—“ That this executive of the Farmers’ Union protests against the policy of the Railways Board and Transport Board in their attempt to divert all traffic to the railways.” MINIATURE RIFLE SHOOTING TOTARA CLUB The best scores at the weekly shoot of the Totara Club are as follow:—D. Marshall 79, W. Smith 78, M. Sinclair 78, S. Wilson 78, D. Seaton 77,. John Carrig 76, K. Morgan 76, L. Morgan 75, S. Taylor 74, J. Richardson 73, A. Richardson 73, S. Perry 72. OAMARU CLUB Following are the results of the weekly shoot of the Oamaru Club:—S. Pile 80 — 3 80, I. Swinard 79-—l—Bo, A. North 79—4—80, W. Munro 79 4 80, E. Taylor 79—5—80, H. Rawson 73 —B—Bo,8—80, A. Aikenhead 76 —7—Bo, T. Kennedy 77 —4—Bo, E. Swinard 77 — 4—Bo, R. Hinkley 75—5—80, A. M'Phail 765 —80, E. Symon 75 —s—Bo, J. Bcardsraore 77—5—80, A. Bastings 71— 12—80, M. Collins 76 —s—Bo, G. Roney 76—6—80, H. Brant 77—5—80, G. Doran 78—1—79, W. Gemmell 75—4—79, E. Sinclair 76—3—79, Slater 74—5—79, H. Koppert 77—1—78. WESTON CLUB The best scores at the weekly shoot of the Weston Club are as follow:—G. Campbell 80, D. Park 79, J. Vernon 78, L. Park 78, W. Laney 78, A. M'Naughton 78, A. Howell 77. L. Campbell 77, J. Howell 77. W. West 77, A. R. M'Naughton 76, L. Clark 75, A. Harvey 74. B. Campbell 74, W. Sewell 74, L. Wilson 74. T.' Campbell won the rifle button, and W. Laney the handicap button. ENFIELD CLUB At the weekly shoot of the Enfield Club A. Anderson won the rifle and handicap buttons. The following are the scores:— A. Anderson 78 —3—Bo. J. Gibson 77—4 —BO, W. Allan 77—2—79, A. Yuill 75—3 —7B, J. Korin 74—3—77. N. Yuill 74—3 —77, D. Elliott 73—3—76. D. Anderson 6if—s—74. W. Fallon 71—3—74, A. Gibson 72—2—74, W. Allan 60—4—73. PERSONAL Queen's Hotel.—Miss Smith, Mr R. Sheat, Mr W. Hitchcox, Mr G. R. Guy, Mr E. Biddle. Mr G. Wilkes (Christchurch), Mr R. J. Walker, Mr H. W. Bundle, S.M., Mr W. A. Hethorington (Dunedin), Mr C. G, M‘Queen (Lovell’s Flat). New Club Hotel.—Mr O. Wood, Mr J. Witchell, Mr R. Poole, Mr N. V. Holmes, Mr K. Thomson, Mr C. O. .Mathias, Mr J. Shearer, Mr B.‘ H. Etheriiigton, Mr E. J. Preen, Mr S. Muirhend, Mr G. F. Copper (Dunedin), .Mr S. 11. Whittaker, Mr J..C. Brown (Wellington). Mr L. G. Le. Cron, Mr J. J. Hake, Mr D. E. Selby (Christchurch), Mr T. S. Little (Chicago), Miramar Hotel.—Miss J. Earland, Mr L, Yardloy, Mr H. Cameron, Sir J. C. Lornncr, Mr L. Hickey, Miss M. Bayden, Miss T. Nelson, Mr J. M. V. Sheppard (Dunedin), Mr and Mrs MacDonald (Pembroke), Mr W. Robson (Waipiata), Mr T. Young (Invercargill), Miss B. Bnl- ■ Inch, Mr J. Ballach (Riversdale), Mr J. Murray (Wellington), Mrs Teraki and ' children. Mrs A. Cartwright and family I (Kurow).

WAITAKi ELECTRIC POWER BOARD MONTHLY MEETING The monthly meeting of the Waitaki Electric Power Board was held yesterday morning. There were present:—Messrs R. Milligan (chairman), J. M. Forrester, A. MTnn'es, W. S. Crombie, R. B. Meek, J. M‘Diarmid. A. B. Lang, J. D. Rutherford, and J. Newlands. Accounts totalling £3585 13s 6d (power fund account £2058 13s 3d, loan account £1527 Os 3d) were passed for payment. The financial statement for the month was as follows, the figures for July. 1934, being shown in parentheses;—Power fund:* Cr balance, £ll3 2s 4d; electricity loan account, dr. balance, £1194 14s fid: receipts: Current, £3871 8s fid (£3727 13s sd); fittings and house wiring. £422 7s 3d (£203 10s lid); cash sales. £52 4s Id (£42 8s sd); total, £4340 Os 3d (£3973 12s fid). At July 31 the total sum of advances under new range terms amounted to £3030 4s 7d, and by payments this had been reduced to £2308 3s fid. For the four months ended July_ 31, the cash receipts from sales of electricity were-£11,542 6s 7d, against an estimated figure only of £11,017. On the other hand, the cost of bulk power had exceeded the amount estimated for this period. —Members expressed gratification at the increased business and receipts, and the secretary was instructed to bring down a full statement to the next meeting. Four applications for financial assistance for new installations were approved. Correspondence from and to the Minister of Public Works in reference to the cost of bulk power supply, was received and approved. , The Waitemata Electric Power Board wrote urging action against the removal of duty on electric ranges, and a telegram was received from the Power Board’s Association to the same effect. The Mayor (Mr M. F. Cooney) wrote requesting delegates to attend a meeting to make preliminary arrangements for fittingly celebrating the completion of the Waiaki Hydro dam.—Messrs Milligan and M'Diarmid were appointed the board’s delegates. . , , The Mayor also advised that he had convened a meeting of public bodies to discuss the question of eliminating the Severn street level crossing—Messrs Milligan and Forrester were appointed the board’s delegates to the meeting. The Hawke’s Bay Power Board wrote advising a remit to form a power boards association—The chairman said he would not like to see a separation of the supply authorities, and members stated that rural boards had the backing of the cities in their request for a flat rate for Government charges.—lt was decided to take no action, the letter being received. The engineer (Mr I. Dalmer) was authorised to attend the Engineers Association’s annual conference to be held on September 10 and 11. The secretary of the Power Boards Association advised that the annual conference would be held on September 12, and that the board was entitled to two voting delegates. —The chairman and engineer were appointed the board’s delegates. The Treasury advised the board of the provisions of the Finance Act concerning the disposal of capital moneys. —Received. The North Canterbury Board wrote advocating a charge of bulk supply of £7 10s per k.v.a., for the next three years.— Mr Milligan submitted a proposal suggested by an engineer, which had been approved, with certain amendments, by Mr Dalmer. Mr Milligan said he was impressed with the suggestion, which briefly meant that boards should have a maximum load allocated, and if that were exceeded then the boards should obtain power at a cheaper rate. The board’s average cost was £8 10s, but if they developed their load to such an extent they should be able to get power very much cheaper and so reduce the average charge. The incentive was to develop the demand for current. —The matter was referred to the Finance Committee for consideration before the delegates went to the conference.

The general treasurer, Presbyterian Church of New Zealand, wrote agreeing to loan conversion, but objecting on principle to violation of original contract. — Received. '

The A.M.P. Society advisedj that the society would not dissent from conversion, but asking that the unfair provision of clause 7 of the Ordef-in-Council be not enforced, and that they be given the opportunity of surrendering existing securities in exchange for new debentures, and then only after, the whole matter Jiad been certified by the solicitors as being in order for conversion, and also asking that an amending Order-iu-Coun-■’eij be procured altering the date of maturity in its case. —The request was agreed to, provided the board had the sanction of the Treasury to arrange it. Mrs Lawlor (Kurow) wrote asking for a contribution towards flooring and lighting of the Kurow Memorial Hall.—lt was regretted that the board could not accede to the request, which would create a pro-, cedent.

A letter from a North Otago resident advised that he had a secret preparation for the preservation of timber.—Referred to the engineer. Mr A. Fyfe (Duntroon) wrote asking that a water right be given to his brother' from the new property at Duntroon. — Granted during the pleasure of the board, and it was also decided to ask the Waitaki County Council for a water right in respect to Mr Maindonald’s house. ENGINEER’S REPORT. The engineer (Mr I. Dalmer) reported that the staff, had continued to be very busy in all departments, and a large number of new consumers bad actually been connected, while inquiries were in hand in many directions. During July nine ranges, seven water heaters, and three motors , were installed. 54 extensions and alterations were carried out, and 21 new consumers were connected. Transfers, disconnections, and reconnections amounted to 62 cases, while 15 wiring installations and 35 radio installations were inspected and tested. The added load for the month was about 102 kilowatts. The re-inspection of wiring installations had been discontinued temporarily to permit of an officer carrviug out the essential earth-testing throughout the board’s area, this work being very important and having to be brought up to date.' A somewhat expensive hightension line was completed in the liakataramea area, all being across private property to save greyer expense by and, of course, under guarantees. Other work, including small extensions and servees, had been carried out at Totara, Waiareka, Enfield, Teanerahi, Island Cliff, Duntroon, and Kurow, while a great deal of work had been taken care of in the town, this latter including considerable extensions of the special pilot wire water-heating system. The board had also dealt with some radio troubles, where these had been definitely located, though it was exceedingly difficult to find the exact source of trouble, even when it was attributed to so-called power-leak or interference at any particular spot. Complaints from Moeraki had been investigated with the assistance of the Post Office radio inspectors, and, while no definite fault of an ordinary nature on the system could be discovered, it would seem that small leaks, or minute discharges, due to salt spray deposits on insulators and fittings, might be the cause of interference to sensitive radio receivers. The only cure was the complete overhaul of these bad sections of line, and be had put this work in hand, and the staff was substituting a higher grade insulator, aud other wise endeavouring to render the lines and apparatus as free from trouble as possible. Some cut-off of supply on certain lines wore being arranged to enable the Public Works Department to carry its Dunedin transmission line over the board’s lines. These cut-offs were being notified to the consumers concerned, find arrangements were being made to give as little trouble us possible to all. The report wag received.

GAS v. ELECTRICITY "AN IMPUDENT LETTER'’ Yesterday morning a letter was received from Cr D. S. Bain (chairman of the Oamaru Borough Gas Committee), by the Waitaki Electric Power Board, in connection with the board’s proposal to make extensive alterations to the board’s offices. Mr Bain wrote that he noticed an amount of £125 was allowed on the estimates for beating. As the board was doubtless aware, the cheapest methods of heating were as follows; —By tiie sun’s rays, by coke or coal fires, by gas fires, and lastly by electric radiator. As the writer presumed the board would certainly not bo using the dearest method, he hastened to solicit business for the Gas Department, and thereby give the board an opportunity to show that it is conserving the interest of the ratepayers by installing a cheaper method of heating. , If gas fires were installed according to the department’s regulations, a beautifully even heat would be obtained and perfect circulation and ventilation would be assured. For the board’s information he gave the following information, the figures of which were indisputable:—T)ne unit of electricity equalled 3412 British thermal units, and one cubic foot of gas equalled 521 British thermal units. As 100 cubic feet of gas cost only 7d at the lowest rate, it followed that the number of British thermal units obtainable for Id was 7443. From, the Government Statistician the information wag obtained that every unit of electricity sold by the board cost, with all overhead charges, approximately lid, so that for Id 2274 British thermal units were obtained, go that the ratio of electricity v. gas in British thermal units was 1 to 3.25. In other words, over three times the heat was given for Id by the use of gag as against electrcity. Further, the cost of installation would be greatly reduced. He added that. recently Cr M'Dermid, in open council, stated that the Gas Department was neglecting a golden opportunity in shop and office heating, as it was a well-known fact that electricity could not compete with gas for this class of heating. It would be evident to members of the board, who, in the past, had served and at present were serving as members of the Gas Committee of the Oamaru Borough Council, that Cr M'Diarmid’s honest statement could not be gainsaid. On behalf of Mr Grenfell (Gas Department manager) they were assured of his ready co-operation and willingness to advise them on all points as regards _ installation. The ’reading of the letter was punctuated by laughter from members of the board. Mr Milligan said he could well believe this to be the most impudent letter ever sent by one local body to another. It was evidently an attempt to be smart, but was very insolent. He suggested that it be received, which was agreed to by members, and added that he thought if it had been sent by a private individual it would not have been even received. In an interview subsequently the Mayor (Mr M. F. Cooney) stated that though the letter was addressed to the secretary of the Power Board from Mr Bain, chairman of the Gas Committee, he took exception to it : being associated with the local body. It did not come from the Borough Council and was purely a personal communication from Mr Bain to the board. HERBERT SCOUTS FIRST BIRTHDAY A very pleasant function took place when the Herbert Scouts celebrated their first birthday. Scoutmaster Andrews presided, and much appreciated items were given by the Scouts, Occupying a prominent place on the well-laden supper tables was the birthday cake, which was cut by Mrs Marshall, president of the Scout Committee, who wished the Scouts many happy returns of their birthday. The following toast list was honoured: — “The King," “The Herbert Troop,’’ District Commissioner Lightwood-Scout-master Andrews; “The Committee,’' Assistant Scoutmaster Mursell —Mrs Marshall; “The Patrol Leaders,” Assist-’ ant Scoutmaster Gray—Scouts Campbell and Barry; “ The Cubs,” Scout Craig— A. M'Eacheran and D. Gray: “The Girls’ Life Brigade,” Scout Diehl—Misses Kroon, Irvine, and Craig. A toast to the Morrison and Barry families for the free use of the hall throughout the year and for many kindnesses was proposed by Scoutmaster Andrew's and responded to by Scout Barry. Commissioner Lightwood spoke to the boys .on. the influence good Scouts had in any' community. ..' WOMEN’S DIVISION, FARMERS’ UNION WAITAKI BRANCH The president (Mrs Chapman) presided over a very good attendance of members and visitors at the monthly meeting of the Waitaki branch. Mrs M'Donald was appointed to fill the position of secretary in place of Miss G. Chapman, who is leaving the district. Appreciation was expressed of Miss Chapman’s services, and best wishes were extended to her for her future. Mrs Chapman gave an enteresting report on the executive meeting held in Oamaru, and a very interesting demonstration of faueywork was given by Mrs Corlett, who was accorded a hearty vote of thanks. Afternoon tea was dispensed by the hostesses (Miss Addison and Mrs A. Cuthbertson). An invitation was accepted from the Hildertliorpe branch to attend its birthday party to-morrow. One new member was elected. AIREDALE-ROSEBERY BRANCH At the monthly meeting of the Aire-dale-Rosebery branch, the president (Mrs A. Lory) occupied the chair. The president gave a report of the executive meeting, and members were mostly in favour of securing a dressmaker for the branches. . „ . „ The roll call, “Uses of Vinegar, brought forward much information. A short concert programme was presented, songs being contributed by Mesdames A. Lory, W. Ballantyne, Miss I. Hoskins, and' a recitation by Miss B. Stephens. Two excellent competitions were held, after which afternoon tea was served by the hostesses (Mrs A. Lory and Miss Stephens). ■ COMMUNITY SING The Opera House was packed last night for the weekly community sing, the exceptionally large crowd being a tribute to the visiting Nelson footballers. A happy hour was spent under the leadership of Messrs G. Dickel and J. Weir, with Mrs Loper at the piano. Racorchestra played several much appreciated selections. The Deputy Mayor (Mr K. Fa mil ton) extended a warm welcome to the visiting footballers, Mr Freeman (manager) returning thanks onbehalf ot the team, the members of which joined heartily in the singing, while the Maori members of the party gave a naka. STEWARD SETTLEMENT BOARD The chairman (Mr James Gibson) presided at a meeting of the Steward Settlement Water Race Board yesterday atterA letter was received from the Minister ot*l eternal Affairs authorising the fc-vird to levy a rate. The proposed rate to be made and levied, a uniform one of throe-eighths of a penny in the £ on the capital value of all rateable property appearing on the district ratepayers’ list for the year beginning April 1. 1934, and ending March 31, 1935, was confirmed. The 1 commissioner of Crown lands wrote stating that an endeavour would be made to have an area of five acres set aside for a raceman’s cottage.—The board decided to make further investigations. Accounts amounting to £2O 6s fid were passed for payment. LOYAL ALFRED LODGE At the conclusion of the fortnightly meeting of the Loyal Alfred Lodge, members adjourned for a social, at; which tne Rose of Oamaru, Hope of Maheno, and Waiarcka Lodges were entertained. N.G. Bro S. A. Muirhead occupied the chair. The evening was devoted to playing cards and dancing, and the music was supplied by Bros. Upchurch and I'. Mitchell. Much appreciated solos were sung by Bro. bidwards, and Bro. J. Mackie carried out the duties of M.O.

STREET LIGHTING LETTER APPROVED BY BOARD - | The letter forwarded by the secretary * of the Waitaki Electric Bower Board to | the Oamaru Borohgh Council in reference to the analysis' of the street lighting charges, came before the members of the board yesterday morning. It was reported that Mr Deuford prepared the return, and had shown the letter to the town members. The board was not in a position to furnish the information asked for by the Borough Council deputation, for the borough figures only, as the board’s aconuta were not kept on . Mr M‘lnnes asked for the engineer’s i assurance as to the town and country . charges being reasonable, and Mr Midi- 1 gini stated that there were only 45 lamps in the country, of which 23 were i in the vicinity of the borough. Mr Dalmer stated that there was rather more capital expenditure in the j country, and the charges were less per j lamp in town than in the country. i Mr Milligan said that if they took the board’s quote to the borough of £2 12s i fid, it was probably the cheapest in New Zealand, or at any rate among the i cheapest, under similar conditions, not i including a charge made by one depart- j ment to another where the municipal , authority was also the supply authority. | The average rate elsewhere was £3 10s j or £3 15s, as far as they could ascertain, i The Waitaki Board's quote was an extraordinarily cheap rate to the borough, and he was only sorry that it was not appreciated by some of the councillors, ihe board could only do its best in accordance with its policy of giving service at the cheapest possible rate. Mr Dalmer , was satisfied it could not be given at j a cheaper rate. .. . Mr Forrester said he thought they should give all the information possible to satisfy the councillors. Mr Milligan said that had been done. Mr Dalmer said he and Mr Denford had gone into the matter carefully, and had made an honest endeavour; to give the information. .< Mr Meek said the board should reaffirm the report given by Mr Denford. An assurance was given that the board waa not trying to hide anything, and the letter was approved. WAIAREKA SALE FAT CATTLE SCARCE Fat Cattle.—Good fat cattle were very scarce. However, two outstanding tat heifers made £8 and over.—Nortli Otago Farmers’ Co-operative Association sold.. For W. Ballantyne, 1 steer £4 10s, 1 heifer £4 10s; T. Breen, 1 cow £4 15s; Mrs Kennedy (Windsor), 1 cow £4; L. A. Fox ( Ardgowan), 2 steers £6 , Dalgety and Co. sold: For A. Malcolm (Tapui). 1 heifer £8 ss. 1 £8; A. J. Sheat (Windsor Park), 1 steer £7, T £o 10 |‘tore Cattle—North Otago Farmers” Co-operative Association sold: L ( or i* Breen (Totara), cow and calf £2 2s Offi cow and calf £1 ss, 2 heifers IBs; H. Brooker, 1 cow 10s, 1 7s fid; AV. A. Morricc (Totara), 1 cow 10s. National Mortgage and Agency Company sold: For client. 1 black cow, 17s fid, Bruce Christie and Co., sold: For a client, 4 heifers 30s. Dairy Cows—Prices for dairy cows still remain low, and there is little demand.—^North Otago Farmers Co-opera-tive Association sold: For MrsJ. Maine--son (Enfield); 1 cow £3 7s fid;, John Foddie (Ardgowan), 1 ccnw £3.——^Dalgetv and Co., sold: For E, C. Thompson, (Oamaru), 1 cow £3_ .las.-—-Bruce Christie and Co.;, sold: .For E. A. Watson .(Enfield), 1 Jersey heifer £3 12s fid; a client, I Jersey cow, £1 ss; Mrs Lawrence (Ardgowan). 1 aged cow 15s. Fat Sheep—There was a very small yarding of fat sheep. Ewes made up to 19s fid, and wethers up to 23s fid. ihe fat wethers offering were only ,of ordinary condition. —North Otago Farmers Co-operative Association, sold: I 1 or A. MTntosh (Awamoa), 12 wethers 23s fid. Dalgety'and Co. sold: For J. Pfiwer (Waiareka), 9 wethers 235. National Mortgage and Agency Company sold: lor J. A. Newlands (Incholme), 13 ewes 19s fid, 13 19s 3d; I. Shaffer (Queens Flat), 11 ewes 17s fid, 9 16s» 6d; P. Collins (Kurow).. 10 wether hoggets 20s;. Pigs.—There was a large, yarding ot pigs at yesterday’s sale—Bruce’ Christie and Co’., sold: For W. Gilchrist (Ardgowan), 2 weaners lls 6d,. 210 s 6d, 10s; S. Craig (Pukeuri), 2 weaners 16s, 3 15s; a client’. 3 weaners 13s, 9d,, 1 10s, L 7s fid; W, R. Gillett (Georgetown). 2 weaners 15s, 1.12 s fid: a, Ngapara client, 3 weaners 15s fid, 4 155,; 214 s; Colin Watson (Maheno), 6 weanerst 14s, 1 10s; an Alma client, 2 slips los fid. 1 12s 6d; Mrs Brown (Waiareka), 4 slips 18s; J. F. Rowlands (Enfield), 1 weaner 14s fid, 3 14s, 2.135. 6d, 1 lls, J. C. Campbell (Five Forks), 2 weaners. 12s fid, 2 lls fid, 1 10s fid; D. Gibson (Waianakarua), 2 weaners 13s fid, A 13s; O. Selman (Georgetown), 15 weaners 14s fid, 1 13s 6d; a Kaurn Hill client, 4 stores £1: J- Smith (Windsor), 2 stores 22s fid; W. Smith (Herbert), 2 stores 18s. •_ , ~ Special Entry—The four-year-o d Clydesdale stallion.. Fyvie Review, sold by the National Mortgage and Agency Company on behalf of a client brought £2O. • . ■ ' ” ' MAGISTRATE’S COURT The weekly sitting of the Oamaru Magistrate’s Court was commenced Yesterday morning before Mr H. W. Bundle, Donald Martin was fined ss, with costs (10s), for riding a bicycle at night without a light. ■ Henry Morse Willetts appeared on remand on a charge of breaking and entering the warehouse of Elizabeth Hodges at Wairaate and committing the crime of theft.—Constable Marshall appeared for the police and Mr E. D. H. Swindley for the accused.—The police applied for a further remand for seven days toWaimate. —Mr Swindley said that this was the fourth remand, and. it. was surely time that some finality should be reached. There was no reason why the lower court proceedings should not be disposed ot. He intended to ask for a separate hearing for the accused in the Supreme Court at Tiraaru. —Mr Bundle stated that the police should state when they would proceed with the case. The remand was granted till to-day, the police to find out if it was then intended to proceed. Bail was renewed as previously. Gustave Holmquist was proceeded against by the maintenance officer (Mr E. Habersnam) for arrears totalling £do 10s on a maintenance order in respect to his wife. After examining the defendant the magistrate adjourned tne case sine die on condition that the defendant paid the current order of 10s weekly and 2g weekly off the ai rears. William Lawrence preceded on a complaint against Helen Lawrence for variation, cancellation, or suspension ot a maintenance order. —Mr J. H. Mam appeared for tlie complainant and Mr K D H. Swindley for the defendant.— I The order was varied by reducing the amount of arrears to 10s per week, the arrears over £3O being remitted and payment of £ls of this amount suspended tor 1- j months. ■ CRIPPLED CHILDREN’S FUND Mr H. P- S. Familton. secretary of the Oamaru Committee of the Crippled Children’s Fund, has forwarded to Ihe headquarters’ organisation of the health camp movement ns a grant towards the running expenses of the camp to be held next January. Representations were also made by the local committee for an increase in the local quota from 12 tp 18. In acknowledging receipt of the contributions, Mrs Marshall MaeDonalci replied that arrangements would be made for 18 children from Oamaru and that Dr Stevenson, school medical officer tor Otago, would co-operate'with the local committee in the selection of children tor the camp. Preference is to be. given re children of unemployed men, and the ages agreed upon are, gix years to 10 years for boys and six to 13 years for girls. It is hoped to arrange a meeting of the local committee at a later date when Mrs MacDonald intends to be present to discuss the health camp.

NORTH OTAGO MOTOR ASSOCIATION ANNUAL MEETING ! The aiiuual meeting of the North Otaso Motor Association was held last night, the president (Mr S. Holmhs) presiding over j a good attendance of aw* members. Messrs Davis and Sutton, representing the Otago Club, attended the,meeting. Mr Holmes, reviewing the activities, said that through reductions in membership the association held its members and gained a few more. They were on the eve of big signposting work and had supported the suggestion for the elimination i of the Severn street crossing. The motor I camp had been very popular with motor--1 ists, and he acknowledged the _cxcellent service given by Mr and Mrs Lee, who ; were in charge of the camp. The asso- ■ ciation’s relations with the borough and I county councils had been very amiable. , The association had promised £IOO toj wards the purchase of the Glencoe rej serve, and it had had a very satistac- ■ tory year. Their ideal was to. have every i motorist in the district as members of the association. —The annual report and balance sheet were adopted. ~ ( In reply to Mr J. E. Farrell, Mr I Holmes stated that the association was ' pledged to £IOO towards the purchase of ■ the Glencoe reserve provided that the I two councils did the same, but money 1 would not be paid over until the pur- | chase was completed.—The meeting confirmed the action of the executive in promising the grant. The election of officers resulted as follows: —Patron, Colonel J. C. Nichols; president, Mr M. S. Holmes; vice-presi-dent, Bruce Steven; club captain. Air E. I Reid; deputy club captain, Mr W. Gillies; treasurer, Mr J. W. Petrie; auditor, D. V. G. Smith; committee—Messrs J. TV Calder, I. Dalmer, J. .Gertie, R. Jenkins. H. J. Jenkins, A. A. Mays, J. H. Main. J. B. Martin, D. L. Patter- , son. and W. Pankhurst. . . Mr Holmes thanked the, committee for its work during the past year, and a hearty vote of thanks was accorded the executive for good work on behalf of motorists. . f Some discussion ensued on a notice, of motion to change the name of the association to the Automobile Association (North Qtago), Incorporated—Members appeared-opposed to the suggested change of the name, desiring to retain the old name, which was distinctive and.good.— Finally it was decided to defer the matter until the next general meeting, which would enable further inquiries to be made. . ; „ ■ . At the annual meeting of the union in September the. annual subscription was fixed at fl Is. a rebate being allowed of 10s 6d on each subscription. _ Mr T. M. Ball, district engineer, Main Highways Board, gave, an .instructive address on the cost of constructing and the maintenance of roads. He described the ■ conditions of 10,878 miles of roads taken ■ over by the Highways Board 10 years ago, and described the value of the ira- ■ provements undertaken to: cope with the motor traffic. Present maintenance costs varied from £2O to £4OO per ” mile, according to traffic intensity, and „ the average for the last four years was i £IOO per mile. To date £10,000,000 had been spent. The speaker dealt with the , reconstruction required in many places, describing single lane and double-lane traffic and the speed requirements. Large • sums were required for bituminous sealing. while maintenance costs would be £3OO per mile for every four years, or . £75 per mile per year. Other mamten- , ance was fixed at £75 per mile. Re- . shaping of foundations cost £4OO to £IOOO per mile, with a similar cost for an extra depth of metal and sealing (two coats) of . £7OO and £BOO. With a fixed interest and sinking fund, charges would be £3OO per mile. Mr Ball 1 dealt with loose top. maintenance, and, in conclusion, spoke of the progressive construction, the extending of dustless sur- ■ faces, and the gradual rebuilding of bridges. Progress had been satisfactory considering ■ the large mileage and the 1 small population. , Mr Ball was heartily 1 thanked for his address. AWAMOA BRIDGE ■ recenuFwidened ' . The, Awamoa bridge, on the Main South road, was opened for traffic yesterday. An excellent job has been made-by the contractors, and The widened’ bridge will, be of great benefit to motorists, as. in its former narrow condition it was a source. > of danger to , motorists. At. the ..annual meeting of the North Otago Motor Asso;i. ciation last night a hearty vote of thanks was accorded the- Waitaki County Council for carrying but the work. MAJESTIC THEATRE ; : “The Silence of Dean Maitland "will . be shown finally to-night at the Majestic l; Theatre. . This sensation, adapted from the great novel by Maxwell Gray, has been unanimously declared by competent critics to be worthy of a place among the great kinema successes of all turt 1 . John Longdon plays the title role, and gives a- magnificent performance m the immortal role of the young clergyman whose silence over a certain matter costs him so much. ,Mr Longden is supported by a specially chosen cast... This is one of those attractions that will make a lasting appeal, not only to regular theatregoers, but also to those who pick out special features once in a while. The programme in support is a complete reyue. containing about eight items by the pick of Australian artists. ;