CHAIRMAN'S RULING UPSET

Gisborne Times, Volume XXXVI, Issue 3997, 30 July 1913, Page 4

CHAIRMAN'S RULING UPSET

INCIDENT IN COMMITTEE DEBATE. [BT TELEGBAPH PABLIAIIIBfTAET COEBESPOXDEXT] ™ - WELLINGTON. Julv 29. • distance in which the ruling of the newly-appointed Chairman (Mr Malcolm) has been appealed against occurred this even--lO^,scussion 011 the Muff a > cy •. .The bone of contention 1q P V ovls . lon that-no person who e, +G a barn ? ter or solicitor, of at !hh?£ fi 7° yoars - standing, shall be elitrate * appom tmeut as a magisnorthiT- Luddo (Ivaiapoi), in supnrnv7n •j?, end ? lent to delete this temhvt h S . ai 7 * J t was evidently infor thn * H le *° keep the prizes ion members of the legal, professnor a,, 9 ou , to say that ho. was the M?" 8 ? 1 at ? his fact ' ‘"‘seeing how Buddo M “7 Stl > V i J s constituted.” Mr Chairman « fd °ut of order bv the he was 16 ground, firstly.' that secondlv proper motives, and It w 7 ? 1 dK ; ground of irrelevant, that f t U r’ cd b - v Mr Russell (Avon) kon o t l '?- 01 the Speaker he taMinisto, 7 Sl - bject v and the Prime Bill trTiv, J l ?lessxon, they desired the pointme 7 s * u , c 1 a f «rm that all apgo to members of'tlmlf' st i raC ‘ V f sh ° uld a 1 that b , th a mea, ' in « of his words tl -tlhur - 10 had uo desire to impute a ivi lUg miproper. 1 the 4r>nnii de patter was referred to tho Ch r v ° r ’ 1 Lang ruled against word?' nna] .V , Ho ruled that the constitute USed b £ Ruddo did not J any reflection upon tho Goist ”i lt a ol ‘ i , an y member of tho Mindid 'n’nt' IU tbat therefore tho words +].„ q, constitute an infringement of nuta?-? ndl ?P Order regarding the impntation of improper motives.