Thank you for correcting the text in this article. Your corrections improve Papers Past searches for everyone. See the latest corrections.

This article contains searchable text which was automatically generated and may contain errors. Join the community and correct any errors you spot to help us improve Papers Past.

Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image

SILVER GRID MURDER

WHY REHfIEYB WAS-CRANTED.

, LEGAt^AND-MOflMt 'INSAWITY. ■] >v STATEMENT BY THE HUME MINISTEn.' ■; During the sitting of tho Hposo of Eeproseh- '••. ' tatives ; yesterday altornopn'' Mr.yO Laurenson { '; (Lyttelton) said timi he had been requested tol; /■/ ask the Primo' Minister if he.could givo/any.-.: explanation, as to the reasons of tho Govern-/, ment for reprieving a man in Lyttelton Gaol , named Eoberb, who, up' till Saturday, hadboon 1 under sontenco;of death. Therp was:'o^'. , ; strong feeling among a large number of'people,.! V especially-in Canterbury, that; thfl-murder: - yat-:>' a cold-blooded one. Although.petitions in/fay-':•'' our of reprieve had boon circulated.there'.were. .;■ large numbers who -"beliovod ,; that.': Robert* ;7 should not bo reprieved.:. Would tho'Govern-- : ment state tho reasons'' why : he' had been/n>' prioved?,'■: ' .■■' .'..V-.;/,- '■...''',:- > ■ v.■l-'j'.,.:;;^;-';',: , '; Tho Views of, the- Executive ;Councili';:,'!■-^ The Primo/Minister said ho would ; bo Terji' glad to placo before •'., members ■ the:',--' circnin« ■ h stances which guided tho .Administration'-if :> recommbhding his Excellency the. Governor -to - ; y reprieve the sentence.'.-■ After into".':'.'' tho mntter , tho Government were quite ■unam- :■;.. mous in'tho decision .which was come to.-Hi;' ' might further state that his: Excellency/the'/ : jovornor, who presided at tho mooting,of the. '■ jixecutird: Council at ; which .tho .matter/was/?'' finally, dealt; ; with, entertained 'oxactly-l'- the'•; same opinion tfn the. matter,. That might be : ; some satisfaction : to/ those /.who thought A tha', '" inal sertehco of death should bo carried- out-.;■• in every case. The Executive Council hadiUV-.';'.' cided upon, a , repriovb in tho .first: .instance*-;/ partly from the report of. the/radges, partly, '- on tho report of the- doctor,' ana- partly from;'' ho recommendation,of tho jury; and, secondly,v In consemjenco of matter contained'in tho evidence, winch ho would liko to etate,. as it' wat "i ■ an important .matter. ..Tho. Government '■■ Chad X. waited for -no/petitions',: : but,had. dealt '.witH/j. tho whole matter 'without'- delay,..with the ter</,, riblo responsibility' , which. Vtestcd / on/, their.;;; shoulders'in regard to. such 'amattpr.:,' ■';.:' v. ; >-.;■ /■'.-..,' - Judge's. Report to Extcutlyc..,; !;Vj ;i y; The Prime Jliuister ! then'.'read'a., report, on'-, 1 the case submitted ; byVilr.Justice.'Dennistbn.:-.; Tho report stated , , that,- the jury's vordict ,wos',-: entirely justified by- the evidence./ "Th'e/inain/-: defence,"-wrote ■ his iHonqiir, "was that of; in-,/;/ sanity. .On',tbat ppint, tlie jiiry' found! on.an-.V issue put. to. them specifically in-tho , .words bf.'V. the Crimes: that, the .accused, at .'the time',.'; ho. committed'the act, was not labouring under , , •' disease'of ■the" mind-, to 'such, an "extent:' ns\ to V: . ronder. hiiii : 'incniiablo' "of v understanding: .its , nature aud qualitjv-and of'.knowing'-'that :it.'.V was'wrong. In so'finding thoy acted upon■ my ; .>.: direction; ,in : terms-of. the. Act,..that, the legal:-:i presumption:is in-favour of sa'nitj - , and that'.it';; lay upon, the, accused to: bring .himsolf! within v the tho'Act.N'V. They'added,'however'; , the following rider jury' dosires; to'■' add' -j a '■■ very strong 'recommendation to ■ incrcy,'.:dn-v.-- ' tho: grounds '■, that : ;the - : evidence '/clearly •■: shove >.'- : that .accused, \s not .• possessed , of ■■nprmAl 'I* mental and . physical • faculties,. ami tlierfe: is ; . grpvo;doubt as to whether;:at tjie. tiniq"'of com- ; ; : ' mitting the act,.,he.was fully .capable of standing, tho /nature .and/quality, of .the', act,.-v.i and-, of 'knowingitliatVsucliL'flct : was 'ivirong.'/ 1 Thoy have.in'cftebt' said-.that/had:jtjw'. biiusi' ofV. proof of; sanity been )pn'■, the' prosecution; they , '-: would have;found, this-issue in favpuL - of the , ?.' .nCOUScd,;- ;.■..-.,:-..■;;•!.'.■':,.-:;:;, •■■]!'■ 'J ■'"'■X'': ; -".', ; •■;-.■>'" ; ' .' "On : this, point-1- am -not-able tb-.ontircly >! 'concur-'with the,.finding.',..';■;The:.accused .:hadf"' beon'-, one' of several '..lovers; of,tho:murdered)■; woman, , who-had thrown him over for: one.of .> •tho 'others;- ■■>.He. : had- , .remonsirated-; with• her'- : , ; without effect.-',/On.-'iliS.'afternoon -pf. 3)e'ccni-',;-ber ; 17 ho: had , obtained , possession oj. ;a to- '■■ :'vplver. (which ho hadi left .with anethbr person);-'! , ' and' : noxt. /evening, Rafter .a-'.'spniowhatr'angrj'r'-interview, ho fellowed tho' woman intp her, bedroom., and shot/her.-iHe 1 got.out l of .the.hpuE* /; at {pace (probably/ by' a/ ladder used as: a , firt .; - escape), and "took , deliberato ■ steps to. .concealf j his ■-, Bubsequorit;'/ mqvembnti , -'and '■■'•'. evade '■■ suspicion. 'viHo'y was" ; arrested,:' next'.'monv-,i. ing-/, : ' while .. ,in ; . .;■'. tho.!- : , act '■■ of- : . writing; a letter which .was "practically /an 'admission of ..his- having;-shot the wonianjvandiin whieV-'. : ho/ 6tated ( his ' intention..of -^omniiting-.'Bucidti.; .and jntelliftent'Actions.' , '' ; .'.: "All this purposive:, and: intelligentjconra. of action, is, in;-:my.-ppiiiion, iiicpneisteht with ■ the. existericn 'of-' any-- , reaijbnablb'i dpiibt his. , being: sano;without , the legal) definition' bli isanitx which: ■r,.havq'',ulrcaUyr stated../-;TheV :witnesses-.-'for' , tho prosecution.,wore not; cross-' ■ examined/ as to aiiy} indication, pf /mental:'dis-V----;turbance'of the,accused;: and, except as .toisb'm'eVovideiico by -a : - witness." named' Hart as V to/ ', a:. iteevipus; exhibition: \yith a .rovolveri '■'thp. : ovi*'. nenco' as : to his , njental was. the tes- : . timoriy :pf ,: tiro medical: men; as , ' to; tho/result '■'.- of: an examinatibß of ,\the accused I after : his., ar-. rest and 'committal."'This bvidonco, 'soifar/ae:'' it-.affects :to';.qusstion lot,' legal\ sanity,'::came,/ ,iri my. opinion,;, only.:to.:.this—that..thero' whs■• a'remote possibility that ho .'might have com-' , mittedtho act in a'fit of homicidarmaniai the ■ .result, of'.'.m'askid .might havq;.beon -, unable :to/'.understand!! tjioo l 'nature pf:his'. ; act;:y- ;^.-^ft ji',-.';;--.-' , -:-!'.- , -.-:'.-;-;"!!:.,'-'' ■■..-.'!. The •.jury,', libwoyer; revidontly;.intended bj/,. ; this rider.;to,-;express/their,opinion, .that,'-.'of-. ; though there was pot fSufEcient to;,prove "what '; I may.termUogal insanity./the , .accused^vas'in>' a:wider' and.moro popular/soriso morally/:irrc-/ ■sponsible; and; that: consequently- it; was "their ) opinion .and .desire-/that .'■ tlun ■ accused \ should.y :iiot: suffor'.', the' extreme ■ penalry law.'.': But for'- a belief -that :this; expression, of v.be-J ■lief would bo effective,'it is .probable'they tfould:/ have 'disagreed or'ihave '■ 'found,' my direction,' that/the accused was;legally in-:; sane;:- ■/' :: ''..:..':'i.''./! : '/.--"--'f /; , \/ 1 ':■';.'■-'/ ',:■ -~-'.'':-,'-',.;'..,; 'ffledical /Eyiiicncoy ■ / '\^ -. -..' " Tho medical evidence; was. to the effect that?, 'the accused,'(who. is only,■ 21v:years/.of.;.ago);'.*ay.> •physically,- morally, and -montally: what;is' now'/ generally as ;'a,-. , 'dogcherato.'/ : Thie.v conclusion' was founded.on,' his. physical' /ai)-;.-pearaiice'.and-peculiarities and : vjpbu':his;own\ .account of his family history,-which, tlio mbdi."; .: .calmon stated\they .had no ,reason ; 'to think , ' invented.,by.- tho,' .accused: to /suit I .' , tho 'fails,; : // "These:gentlemen,".statedv.the Judgoi■ ."were i ■ ,not. selected/' by-:the : accused , or,' ; his -,advisers,:i but; are tho: holders of _. official/'p'o'sitions,' , and./ t wero; in ,tUeir, oxdinindtion,: acting ".under Goy-." ernment:instructions.;.'.To these;.proofs;of, in-;' i herited' deficiene'es'they., addod tnat-rprobably.': i af ttconsoquelico: of, ■ such' deficiencies—the'lie-- : cused'had 'still further ■, debased■• himself./by,; i excessive alcoholism and other:means.:.;'::■;' '.':•:■•• .'.'Their conolusiohs ) ' , jtlio ; report went ion.'.'cer-/ '■.- tainly justifies/that- part.-of/tlio/jury.'s, rider'; 1' which- hnds ■that- , the accused -possessed: i of normal,;mbntal, .'and:physical;.faoullies.'V-.";, J i ; -"Thecaso is not, one in .wliich/apy assistance'! i could be obtained-'* by. further -inyestigatibn.'.' 1 The jury and the. medical ■ivitiiefsts'lwvo come; \ to the,'conclusion -that- tho .accused,':though at/ ) tho ;tiino of the 'commission 'of^.'tho/ act/nPI ( . proved to. bo losally irresponsible, whs at least ;■ i on the border, lino of, such irresponsibility. 11: . can, only submit these observations and; the'ovk ; v denoo on which ..they are founded;.: ::.;>'. : /:;/'. J..' s ',' "I have felt myself bound to stdte.nijr opiriioi/ ; [ on tho question of the: legal : sanity ; ofil-tht ■ }] accuEcd.' It:;will/.bo-.for./his/Excellency/tlw; ".. Governor and his: advisers to< .consider, how. fair the yontli'jot: the acousedi. liis inherited.-'.liimta-! tions and' disabilities, his admittedly-, 10w.,' men-.. .' tal nnd' morale standard,. ;:taken.:/with ythi', . strongly-expressed -opinion of /.t'ab/iury,' who ,'•' 'convioted him,'.supported'; by /tlio./opinions' of' t tho:official medical:experts who examined'Kinj.; .' as to his moral ; .reeii6nsibilityi'as-.distinguished.: 3- : from legal insanity, should: warrant: tho/clem> ency-. of..tho.CrowiLbeing extended to : him'.is: tho iemiesionof the/capitaVpeiialtyi" '../J. :; :■ , ■•'./■. ' : ;,.^"A ; Dangerous, Degenerate; , !;;//i;V.//;:Z • /Sir Joseph quoted an/extract from tlie dbctprV . roport. 'The doctor- considered.Eobcrts to'/bu' s a dangerous degeuerato Tlitre were eyniptoma" 0 which were consistent with' epileptic ausanity, 1 r crime he (the;doctor) would, hesitation j, .in declaring him ih'sanp; '. Hoborts might- licjfe'j acted, under, an jnsano' impulsoi.i'//- , ■ /:.\,/M/', . No man, (contiiiUed tho Primo/llinistcr).;who, - lmd'to calmly nnd judicinUy , 'e.\smino : into the, ' facts'could liavo comf to" tiny /other conclusioni than that if tho Executive. hiidZ/ordcrcd.: ,tho. 1 extremb penalty /to he tarried-out it Srould' o have/been a .flrong'. thing to hnvo. dbno.-v-: '/.v :, r; ■■.■'V-;'\;---W.--j'v'pefini'llon'-.,qf!:..insanlty;'-.> IV-.-.-- ; '■.'jj'-'.-i:'; C ; Mri .'Wllfprd'thought that/tlie/ZGoypriimdnt e should -consider, the nocossity of/altering 'the: c . legal insanity. ;Tf6 would.sugifnst. - that tho' inatter \ slipuld' bo referred .to.;th'o f Minister for Justico nud v lnw.,officers;., lt.Wns s. 1 hisiopinion that il/ definition: should bo froriiei t on the .suggistion of tho repbrt : of the judges/ o \vho sat , at Homo in .regard to tho subject/ q somo time ago. •'"■ : " ' ""'" : '■■-•); The Primo Minister slated that Mr.* Justi«: : Ronniston hnd called on Dr. Findlay thai . morning, and entirely , approved of tho commu- , tation of tho Bontoncc. . '.:..: .-,i---r.'

Permanent link to this item

https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/DOM19091130.2.45

Bibliographic details

Dominion, Volume 3, Issue 677, 30 November 1909, Page 7

Word Count
1,304

SILVER GRID MURDER Dominion, Volume 3, Issue 677, 30 November 1909, Page 7

SILVER GRID MURDER Dominion, Volume 3, Issue 677, 30 November 1909, Page 7

Help

Log in or create a Papers Past website account

Use your Papers Past website account to correct newspaper text.

By creating and using this account you agree to our terms of use.

Log in with RealMe®

If you’ve used a RealMe login somewhere else, you can use it here too. If you don’t already have a username and password, just click Log in and you can choose to create one.


Log in again to continue your work

Your session has expired.

Log in again with RealMe®


Alert