Thank you for correcting the text in this article. Your corrections improve Papers Past searches for everyone. See the latest corrections.

This article contains searchable text which was automatically generated and may contain errors. Join the community and correct any errors you spot to help us improve Papers Past.

Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image
Article image

LABOUR LAWS.

ARBITRATION. ACT CRITICISED.

»WORSE THAN USELESS." . ,-. r . (bi telkguA.rn—-press .association.) '. ■ - Wcstport, April 7. .■ Mr; J. Marchant, secretary of thq Denniston. Coal Minors' Union, replying to tho \ Wcstport "Timcs's" comment oil tho action of his Union in rosblving to withdraw' from tho Arbitration Actj supplies some of the ■ reasons'influencing tho* vote, of tho majority. MrlrMarchant refers to "the dark shadow of . 'tho menacing wing of the Arbitration Court," : ' and continues: —. . ''We,'in company with the majority of the ■ workers-".of ISow Zealand, are very much dissatisfied with the'unjust administration of the Court of late. It has been preposterous Imagmo a judge so unjust as to give his de; cision previous to hearing evidence; in other cases, absolutely refusing to, hear evidence, , and in each caso giving an adverse decision ' ■against .the workors.' Who, the fact that Mr.' Justice Sim was conversant with the purpose of the' Eight Hours Amendment Bill, and being in possession of that • 11 knowledge (even though ■he could, pick out ' some little technical flaw .in the wording of 1 • the' Bill); who can justify his action in dc- ' foatihg its purpose and overriding the legislation of-the,country? . Imagine the irony of . tho following little episode: A judge .deliberating, as to whether fifteen minutes is sufficient time for men.to(take/ 'tucker,' men,who are • ; toiling all day at . dangerous, occupations, breathing /foul 'and noxious' gases. '.Ho suddenly adjourned the Court'for 75 minutes to 'partake.of lunchthen, discovers' ho \ cannot possibly award those grimy toilers any more ■ than 15 minutes .for crib. But it ; is ;not...'.tlio , ;■'^administration-'alono with vwhich- ' we, ; ;are '• ' dissatisfied,.' 'but - the . constitution of Court -also. We have :been: taught, that''thb."Arbitration judgo iis<onfallible aiid, all-powerful. In our-recent , dispute; re the bank-to-bank / question, _wo . wisned to appeal, against the judge's unjust decision, and were informed by :the legal pro- \ fession that wo could not do this; wo could merely apply for a writ of prohibition against ; his jurisdiction: arid have our" case tried in the Supremo Court. ' The next development of tho'. case' .was; the-flying visit of tho Pre-. • mier arid Minister for Labour, who informed • us that jthe decision of the Arbitration Court ■ was-final and,. binding. Now we have tho matter in a nutshell: — ■;.' . "The Arbitration judge is infallible and all-powerful, and I tliink his administration proves boydnd doubt that he is not •f- impartial'. •' Therefore,'-1 cannot possibly'', agree 'with you when you assert that the • ■ repeal , of' tho'Arbitration Act would be disastrous •to tho truo' interests of ■ ■ labour." ... . - Mr. P; Callagharij a member of the Denniston 'Union Committee, also condemns the Act-because, there are two representatives of ' capitals/the judge ; being drawn from the . capitalistic class. It has failed to benefit • the worker, as in 14' years' there has been a decrease in .the .purchasing power of wages ' - of-'4s! in the 'pound.- No award has been made for Denniston since the. 1900. --The ''agreements' come to could be, bettor,-arrived at ' .without Arbitration Court > and . its . expense to; employers . 'and'.employees.. Arbii tration' has • retarded 'industrial (organisation. He 'agrees'that-arbitration' is worse than useless; .it its day is done.. ■ • ■ " The question is riot how much of our labour's' products wo - shall receivc,, but • - that we'shall'get-':tK'e'whole; then we shall . "notvbtf bothered about arbitration and r -strikes; in fact,:we are becoming Socialists."

Permanent link to this item

https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/DOM19080408.2.17

Bibliographic details

Dominion, Volume 1, Issue 167, 8 April 1908, Page 5

Word Count
536

LABOUR LAWS. Dominion, Volume 1, Issue 167, 8 April 1908, Page 5

LABOUR LAWS. Dominion, Volume 1, Issue 167, 8 April 1908, Page 5

Help

Log in or create a Papers Past website account

Use your Papers Past website account to correct newspaper text.

By creating and using this account you agree to our terms of use.

Log in with RealMe®

If you’ve used a RealMe login somewhere else, you can use it here too. If you don’t already have a username and password, just click Log in and you can choose to create one.


Log in again to continue your work

Your session has expired.

Log in again with RealMe®


Alert