I CHRISTIAN SCIENCE. (To the Editor.)
1 Sir,- —In her last letter Miss Madge ' Bell states that 'Christian Scientists: ' accept the first chapter of Genesis as the j i record of the creation of God's universe. I ' Sow, in that chapter it is declared that - ! God made "sun and moon, the earth, > yegetation, and. animals. Theee are •- material ■ Therefore • God created matter. But Mrs. Eddy 1 asserts that "Nothing possesses reality '■ or existence except God"; that "God; 1 being all, nothing is matter"—or matter! • is nothing. So the' universe God created i —earth, sun, moon, etc.—has no reality > or existence,.and being matter, is nothi ing. Will Miss Bell tell us in plain I English the answer, .to this Christian - Science riddle? Speaking this week r at, the, meeting of the British Medical I Association at' Nelson, Dr. s Gjbhs advor cated the establishment of an institute 1 for studying the causation and prevent tion of disease. From the Christian i Science point of view such an institute would do more harm than for the only real disease is belief in disease. . Christian Science teaches sickness is caused by believing it' exists, and to prevent it we have only_ to persuade purselves that it has no existence. What fools these doctors are! In my,previous letter I asked this question: "If Miss 1 Bell, fractured her skull would she try 5 to cure it by right thinking, or would 5 "she send for a'doctor?"- Miss Bell's I answer to this plain'question is .is fol- • lows: "If Christian Scientists find their C; knowledge of, or faith in, Gdd, is unequal > to their proving that God supplies all I their needs, they are free to ask help • from surgeons if they wish to do so, but ; they know that the limitation lies not , with Gpd, but "with them." Help!—l ■ am, etc., NORMAN E. BURTON. • (To the Editor.) Sir,—Miss Bell has become ■ aware "how great a matter a little fire.kindl leth." The conclusions drawn from 3 newspaper correspondence are for - yonr I wide - circle of intelligent .readers .as , well as for the writers. But even so, it ' might be. hoped that .the ;-writers' would j. sometimes see eye to eye when the truth is 'presented. Miss Bell now &iys that " The • first , chapter of Genesis' is ( ' accepted by over a million Christian i'-Scientists as the record, etc." Are v we to understand from this that they all, r like Miss Bell, reject the second chape ter? This also is Bible. Miss Bell 8 refers to the claims made by myself, '• but this is hardly correct, as I merely fc presented for her acceptance the Bible P in its own defence. She goes on to say !•' that a Hebrew scholar says of the word 1 God in Genesis that it " refers in the • original to.a metaphysical—not a physin cat , being." But the Bible:will instruct v her that God is both physical and metaT physical since the Incarnation, and that t in Jesus Christ "dwelleth the fulness-.of. i, the Godhead bodily." This also will c have its application to the later portion r of Miss Bell's* letter, where she quotes s mc, " the infinite is infinitely human— a infinitely man," and. adds, then ."there :■. can be no place for God, who is spirit, i since there-cannot be anything beyond .infinity." But surely spirit is human— . it is man, Divine man, not an abstrac- £ tion. It is not surprising that the , infinite bothers Miss Bell; it is "the .'. difficulty of philosophy,?'- - but some • people seem anxious" to make it a c refuge for their lack of reasons. Miss Belle "best definition," however, brings her well within the human scope, when she says that "God fs incorporeal, divine, supreme, infinite' mind, spirit;' . soul> principle, life, truth, love." Will ' she: do herself the kindness to just reflect; upon how many of these attrie butes Jesus Christ claimed as. His own. •p If.she" willnot accept Him:whois ''Gpd 1 with* us," and thus -the only God-we " cankqov, God.not ■with, us being deafly incomprehensible, how can she claim (in speech) to be Christian ? Christian b Science in such a case is a misnomer.— I am, etc., ROBERT STRONG.
Permanent link to this item
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/AS19260220.2.151.8
Bibliographic details
Auckland Star, Volume LVII, Issue 43, 20 February 1926, Page 15
Word Count
695I CHRISTIAN SCIENCE. (To the Editor.) Auckland Star, Volume LVII, Issue 43, 20 February 1926, Page 15
Using This Item
Stuff Ltd is the copyright owner for the Auckland Star. You can reproduce in-copyright material from this newspaper for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 3.0 New Zealand licence. This newspaper is not available for commercial use without the consent of Stuff Ltd. For advice on reproduction of out-of-copyright material from this newspaper, please refer to the Copyright guide.
Acknowledgements
This newspaper was digitised in partnership with Auckland Libraries.