EDUCATION: TEACHERS' SUPERANNUATION FUND.

Appendix to the Journals of the House of Representatives, 1910 Session I, E-09

E.—9

1910. NEW ZEALAND.

EDUCATION: TEACHERS' SUPERANNUATION FUND.

Laid before Parliament in pursuance of the Act.

CONTENTS. Page Part 1. Extract from report of Minister .. .. .. .. .. ..1 „ 2. Report of Board, with additional statements to those prescribed by regulations .. 2 Statements prescribed by regulations ~ ~ ~ .. .. ~ 3-10 No. 1. EXTRACT FROM THE THIRTY-THIRD ANNUAL REPORT OF THE MINISTER OF EDUCATION. The Teachers' Superannuation Act, which was passed by Parliament on the 31st October, 1905, and came into force on the Ist January, 1906, was amended by a supplementary Act on the 29th October, 1906. Every person who at the date of the coming into operation of the principal Act was permanently employed for not less than twenty hours a week in the Education service had the option of electing within six months to become a contributor to the fund. Those who so elected became " original members," and, as such, are entitled to special benefits. A person who did not so elect to join the fund at its commencement might, however, be allowed to join it on certain conditions to be imposed by the Superannuation Board. All teachers in public schools and in Native and other schools under the control of the Education Department who were subsequently permanently employed were compelled to become contributors as from date of appointment; persons in tho Education service had the option of becoming contributors. On the 10th October, 1908, the former Acts were repealed by the Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908, Part I ; but existing contributors were allowed six months in which to elect to remain subject to the provisions of the former Acts if they so desired. On the 24th December, 1909, this Act was amended, providing among other things for the extension of the time allowed in which to make the election referred to above to the 30th

I—E. 9,

E.—9

2

June, 1910 ; the Act also fixed a maximum retiring-allowance of £300 per annum in the case of persons who become contributors to the fund after the passing of the Act (24th December, 1909). The chief difference between the Act of 1908 and the former Acts affected the basis of calculation of the retiring-allowance of a contributor. The retiringallowance was to be one-sixtieth of the average rate of salary received during the three years next preceding retirement, for each year of service, provided that in no case may the allowance exceed two-thirds of that salary : under the former Acts the basis had been one-sixtieth of the total salary received by the contributor during the period of contributing to the fund (or, in other words, one-sixtieth of his average salary for each year of service during the whole period of contribution), and, in addition, in the case of original members, one one-hundred-and-twentieth of the salary during the years of service between Ist January, 1878, and Ist January, 1906, with a further proviso that in no case should an original member receive a retiring-allowance of less than £52 per annum. By the same Act of 1908 the right of persons employed on Ist January, 1906, as teachers in public schools or under the Education Department to be admitted at a future date was taken away. At the end of 1909,— The number of contributors was .. . . .. . . .. 3, 152 Of whom members under Part IX of Education Act, 1908, number . . 144 The annual rate of contribution paid as at the end of the year was over £35,500. The number of retiring-allowances in force was 216, representing an annual charge of over £9,500. Of these,— Ordinary allowances were .. .. .. .. 120, representing £7.31<> Allowances in medically unfit cases .. .. 17, „ 1,013 Allowances to widows .. . . . . . . 38, „ 689 Allowances to children .. . . .. 41, „ 533 The balance at the credit of the fund and invested by the Public Trustee at the end of the year was . . . . . . . . . . £118,615 The average rate of interest earned by the investments at the end of the year was 478 per cent. ____ __ _ No. 2. FOURTH REPOET OF THE BOARD CONSTITUTED BY THE PUBLIC SERVICE CLASSIFICATION AND SUPERANNUATION AMENDMENT ACT (PART I), 1908. Fok the Year ending 31st December, 1909. The Honourable the Minister of Education. Sir,— Wellington, 19th July, 1910. The Board has to submit the following report for the year ending 31st December, 1909. The number of contributors to the fund on the 31st December, 1908, was 2,931, composed of 2,416 original members and 515 ordinary members. Under the provisions of Part II of the Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1909, the benefits provided for under the Act of the same title in 1908 were extended conditionally in regard to age and length of service of contributors, as from the date (Ist April, 1910) of the Act coming into force in that respect. It was also provided, as from the date (24th December, 1909) of the passing of the Act, that no person who became a contributor after that date shall be entitled on his retirement from the Education service to a retiringallowance exceeding three hundred pounds (£300) per annum ; and that the operation of section 24 of the Act, 1908, be extended to the 30th June, 1910 —those contributors who had already made the election therein referred to (to remain subject to the provisions of the original Act—Part IX of the Education Act 1908) were also given the option of revoking such election.

3

E— 9

. Details of the members of the fund on 31st December, 1909, grouped according to their status, are given in the following tables : —

A. Total Number of Contributors who have joined and left the Fund since its Establishment (1st January, 1906, to 31st December, 1909).

B. Statement of Membership as from 1st January, 1906.

C. Statement of Contributors on the Register as at 31st December, 1909, grouped according to Rate of Contribution per Cent. of Salary.

From these tables it will be found that there was a net increase of membership of 221 during the year 1909. Those members who have elected to remain subject to the provisions of Part IX of the Education Act, 1908, are persons whose service or salary would not insure a retiringallowance exceeding the minimum allowance of £52 per annum provided for under that Act, and who otherwise desire to secure those benefits which it provides.

Number. P. Total. Annual Salary. Annual Contributions. M. 'otal entered (including increases in salary and contributions) 'otal discontinued (including reductions in salary and contributions) 1,708 1,973 3,681 & £ 606,076 42,486 a. 0 a. 0 235 294 529 94,836 6,942 0 0 Total existing at 31st December, 1909 1,473 1,679 3,152 511,240 , 35,544 0 0

Original Members. Or«i Number Admitted. Left, at End of Admitted. Period. 2,720 127 2,593 219 .50 138 2,505 j 197 OrUi iary Members. iry Members. Total Nu; nher at End of Period. Name of Act. Number Left. at End of Number. Period. Period. teachers' Superannuation Act, 1905, and Amendment Aot, 1906 )itto ... 219 2,812 Fifteen Months ending 31st March, 1907. • 39 377 2,882 Year ending 31st March, 1908. Part IX, Education Act, 1908. ~~r~ 4 2,345* 164 Part I of Public Service Classification and Superannuation Amendment Act, 1908. •2,409 19 2,767 Niimlwr Total Number at End Number. of Feriod I 2,931 Nine Months ending 31st December, 1908. •20 144 334 93 3,008 3,152 Year ending 31st December, 1909. * Includes 2,252 transferred to Part I, Public. Service Classification and Superannuate >n Amendment Act, 1908.

Members under the Contribution per Cent. Members Provisions of Part I of the Public u J? in 'tTV under Part IX of the Service Classification when First Contribution Bdacat ion Act, 1908. and Superannuation Amendment became payable). Act 1908 Total. M. F. Total. M. P. Total. M. P. Total. 5 6 7 8 9 10 8 5 7 10 13 2!) 4 8 L8 L7 lit (i 12 13 25 27 32 35 510 189 212 189 132 169 925 263 220 122 59 18 1,435 452 432 311 191 187 518 194 219 199 145 198 929 271 238 139 78 24 1,447 465 457 338 223 222 Totals 72 72 144 1,401 1,607 3,008 1,473 1,679 3,152

E.—9

4

D. Progressive Annual Table of Receipts and Expenditure (1st January, 1906, to 31st December, 1909).

E. A Statement of Members of the Fund who have attained the Statutory Age of Eligibility for Retirement is shown as follows:—

1. Statement of Contributors, showing Annual Rates of Salaries and Contributions as at 31st December, 1909.

The following table shows the progress of ti U1T since its estal blishment :— Period ended. j Total Num- Total Contributions ber of Con- (inoluding tributor8 at Government End of Subsidy) received Period. during Year. Total Interest received during Period. Total Income. Exp^ ure . 31st March, 1907... 31st March, 1908... 31st Dec, 1908 ... 31st Dec, 1909 ... March, 1907.. March, 1908.. Dec, 1908 .. Dec. 1909 .. _ s. d. 2,812 37,446 3 6 ;; 2,882 32,688 14 6 .. 2,931 27,153 10 6 .. 3 ,i52 42,121 11 1 2,812 2,882 2,931 3,152 £ s. d. 863 15 7 2,128 13 1 2,373 10 2 4,751 9 7 £ s. d. £-s. d. 38,309 19 1 3,576 2 11 34,817 7 7 7,328 12 9 29,527 0 8 7,278 4 7 46,873 0 8 10,935 10 2 Totals 139,409 19 I 7 10,117 8 5 149,527 8 0 29,118 10 5 Balance, £120 ( 408 17s. 7«i.

Age: Years. Male. Number. j Female. Age : Years. Number. Conditional Retirement. Over 60 but not over 61 „ 61 „ 62 „ 62 „ 63 „ 63 „ 64 „ 64 „ 65 22 19 6 11 16 22 19 6 11 16 Over 50 but not over 51 . 51 „ 52 „ 52 „ 53 „ 53 „ 54 „ 54 „ 55 16 12 9 15 5 57 74 r>7 Unconditioth ■I Retirement. Over 65 but not over 66 . 66 „ 67 . 67 „ 68 „ 68 „ 69 . 69 „ 70 „ 70 3 1 Over 55 but not over 56 , 56 „ 57 , 57 „ 58 „ 58 „ 59 . 59 „ 60 „ 60 4 1 4 5 5 19 4 1 4 5 "5 Totals ... b 80 19 80 76

Number. M. P. Total. Annual Salary. Annual Contributions. Contributors at 31st December, 1908 ... New contributors entered during the year ending 31st December, 1909 Increase in salaries and contributions by promotions during the year 1,438 76 1,493 258 2,931 334 £ 454,646 37,327 s. d. 0 0 0 0 £ a. d. 33,057 0 0 1,185 0 0 41,670 0 0 2,975 0 0 Totals 1,514 1,751 3,265 533,643 0 0 37,217 0 (I Contributions discontinued during the year ending 31st December, 1909, by resignation, &c. Decrease in salaries and contributions during the year 41 72 113 17,485 4,918 0 0 0 0 1,246 427 0 0 0 0 Totals at 31st December, 1909 1,473 1,679 3,152 511,240 0 0 35,544 0 0

E.—9

5

Of the number of contributors who retired during the year 28 (including 4 medically unfit cases) were granted annual allowances (£2,391 14s. 6d.); 7 widows and 15 children, the representatives of 8 contributors who died, were granted annual allowances (£321) and also a refund of contributions (£389 3s. 2d). The total number of retired contributors on account of whom annual allowances were granted during the period was therefore 36. To the legal representatives of one contributor who died before he was entitled to a pension was granted a refund of the contributions made by the deceased to the fund amounting to £46 15s. Bd. To 76 contributors who voluntarily retired from the Education service before becoming entitled to participate in the benefits of the fund contributions amounting to £1, 389 3s. 4d. were returned. The total number of contributors who retired from the Education service during the period was 113.

2. Particulars of Contributions discontinued during the Year ending 31st December, 1909.

Seven pensioners died during the year, leaving five widows and five children under fourteen years of age, to whom annual allowances were granted; five children having attained the age of fourteen years their allowance consequently ceased; and one pensioner, having failed to reestablish his claim to an allowance as being medically unfit, was, in view of the medical report furnished, informed that his allowance would no longer be maintained. Further details are given in the following table :—

Number of Contributors. Annual I Rei late at Date of iirement. Allowances granted. How discontinued. P. 1 M. Salary. Contributions. Pensions: Other Paya . l 13 » ments (uonAnnual Rate, j reourr J ng) By death before pension entered a £ s. d. '£ a. d. £ s. d. upon — Contributions paid to personal representative Leaving widow or child By voluntary retirement Medically unfit — (a.) Not over fifteen years' service (b.) Over fifteen years' service By retirement at pension age ... 1 8 L8 63 1 8 76 245 2,205 9,837 17 3 0 205 12 0 551 15 0 46 15 321 0 0 389 3 1,389 8 8 2 4 4 15 "9 4 24 1,005 4,193 80 9 0 390 13 0 342 15 3 2,048 19 4 Totals 41 72 113 17,485 1,245 12 0 2,712 14 6 1,825 2 2

E.—9.

6

3. Statement of Retiring-allowances for the Year ending 31st December, 1909.

(1.) 12.) Details of C (3.) Details of Column (2). Total Retiring-allowances. Ol) AUainment of Retiring- Medically untit Particulars. ageMedically unfit. Widows. Chi ildren. Number. Number. Number. [ ~S Amount. Amount. ; Amount. M. F. £ M. P. M. F. £ s. (1. £ B. a. £ s. d. Retiring-allowances as at 31st December, 1908 79 : 89 168 7,221 6 5 61 39 5,515 19 5 8 9 907 3 0 Retiring-allowances granted during the year 26 24 50 2,712 14 6 15 9 2,048 19 4 4 ... 342 15 2 at retirement of contributor Retiring-allowances granted to widows and ... 10 10 155 00 j ... children of deceased annuitants i i Number. Amount. £ s. d. 26 473 4 0 7 126 0 0 I . I Number. M. I F. "' I I Amount. £ s. 325 0 195 0 d. 0 0 ; io 15 7 8 5 90 0 0 ... 5 65 0 0 Total ... ... ... 105 123 228 10,089 0 11 76 48 7,564 18 9 12 9 1,249 18 2 Retiring-allowances discontinued during 9 4 ■ 13 550 8 11 4 ... 248 11 1 3 1 236 17 10 yg ar * 1 ■ i ' ■ Retiring-allowances existing at end of year 96 119 215 9,538 12 0 72 48 j 7,316 7 8 9 8 1,013 0 4 9 1,249 18 2 1 236 17 10 38 689 4 0 17 28 2 3 585 0 65 0 0 0 9,538 12 0 I 72 48 7,316 7 8 8 1,013 0 4 38 689 4 0 15 , 25 ! 520 0 0 * P< vrticulars of Retiring -allowances discontinued during the 1 car. How discontinued — By death By expiry ... ... 6 1 7 433 8 11 4 ... 248 11 1 2 1 184 17 10 ... 3 3 6 117 0 0 ... 1 ! ... 52 0 0 7 6 433 117 8 11 ; 4 ... 0 0 248 11 1 2 1 184 17 10 1 ... 52 0 0 2 3 65 0 o Total 9 4 ! 13 550 8 11 4 ... 248 11 1 | 3 | 1 236 17 10 550 8 11 I 4 ! ■ 248 11 1 I 1 — 3 ! 1 I 236 17 10 •2 3 65 0 0 Progress of Betiring-alloivances since Establishment of Fund to 31sl December, 1909. Total granted ... Total discontinued ... 114 128 242 ... 18 9 27 10,639 3 1,100 11 3 83 11 48 7,941 1 624 13 1 14 5 5 9 1,353 18 2 1 340 17 10 39 1 707 18 4 0 0 0 17 32 2 7 637 117 0 0 0 0 Total existing ... 96 119 215 9,538 12 0 72 4S 7,316 7 8 9 8 1,013 0 4 38 689 4 0 15 25 520 0 0

7

8.—9

4. Further Details of Allowances. (a.) Return of Retiring-allowances discontinued during the Year 1st January to 31st December, 1909, and Annual Rate of Allowances granted to the Widows and Children.

(b.) Return of Widows and Children during the Year 1st January to 31st December, 1909, who ceased to be entitled to Benefits.

(c.) Return of Persons in Receipt of Annual Allowances as at the End of December, 1909. (i.) Allowances granted to Contributors who reached the Retiring-age.

Date from which it Annual Rate of Retiring-allowance D , , , —- Discerned. Retirin Sfwance 8 . to Widow, &o. £ s. d. £ s. d. 1. Broughton, John H. : ...Death ... 52 0 0 1 January, 1909 15 6 2. Burton, Frank P.* ... Discontinued 52 0 0 ... 3. Smith, John H.- ... Death ... 80 17 10 31 August, 1909 ... 4. Virtue, Mary E. :: ... 52 0 0 23 May, 1909 ... 5. Baldwin, John ... „ ... 92 11 1 11 January, 1909 6. Hardie, George ... „ ... 52 0 0 1 September, 1909 7. Neill, Eobert ... ... 52 0 0 12 January, 1909 38 18 11 8. Malcolm, Andrew ... 52 0 (I 18 October, 1909 Totals ... ... ... 485 8 11 ... 40 4 5 40 4 5 * Retired on grounds of medical unfitness.

Name Widow or Name. chi]d . „„ . T,,. . Date of Termination 01 of Payment of Allowance. Remarks. 1. Bramley, George S. ... Child 2. Clarkson, Eosina V.* ... „ 3. Duthie, Ivy M. 4. Maber, Winnifred B. ... 5. Selby, Cuthbert C £ 13 March, 1909 ... 13 July, 1909 13 June, 1909 13 \ April, 1909 ... 13 June, 1909 Attained 14 years of age. Total ... 65 (V, * Granted 4th April, 1909; discontinued 12th July.

Ai Name. Occupation. Annual Bate of Allowance nnual Bate Allowance !Of Males. 1 Bannerman, William ... j Teacher, Otago Education Board 2. Barton, James ... „ „ 3. Bedford, Bernard S. .. „ Auckland Education Board 4. Bissell, Edward ... „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... 5. Bonnin, John L. :; ... „ Otago Education Board 6. Boyd, Donald ... Truant Officer, Southland Education Board 7. Browne, Alfred A. ... ; Assistant Truant Officer, Wanganui Education Board 8. Budd, George W. E. ... Teacher, North Canterbury Education Board 9. Bullock, Samuel ' ... „ „ 10. Butcher, Anthony G. ... „ Taranaki Education Board 11 Dale, Joseph ... ... Janitor, Thnaru High School Board 12. Duncan, William ... Teacher, Southland Education Board 13. Dunnett. Andrew* ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 14. Dyer, Henry H. ... „ Wellington Education Board 15. Dyer, Eobert C. ... .. Auckland Education Board 16. Everiss, George ... „ Marlborough Education Board ... 17. Ferguson, William ... „ Otago Education Board 18. Field, John L. ... „ Southland Education Board 19. Fitzgerald, William S. :: Inspector, Otago Education Board 20. Foster, William E.* ... Teacher, South Canterbury Education Board 21. Gerring, Albert ... „ Auckland Education Board 22. Gillman, Alfred I. ... ., North Canterbury Education Board 23. Glenny, Joseph ... „ Auckland Education Board £ s. 52 0 52 0 52 0 52 0 52 0 52 0 58 19 52 0 52 0 52 0 52 0 52 0 120 6 52 0 52 0 52 0 52 0 52 0 251 7 64 18 52 0 52 0 52 0 d. 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 * Allowances granted during the period from 1st January to 31st December, 1909.

E.—9

8

(c.) Return of Persons in Receipt of Annual Allowances —continued. (i.) Allowances granted to Contributors who reached the Retiring-age— continued.

Name. Oocupation. Annual Bate of Allowanoe. Annual Bate of Allowanoe. Males— continued. 24. Goodwin, John S. ... Inspector, Auckland Education Board 25. Goulding, Richard* ... Teacher, Hawke's Bay Education Board ... 26. Gover, Frederick ... „ Wellington Education Board 27. Grant, James ... „ Taranaki Education Board 28 Grevaes, Joseph* ... „ South Canterbury Education Board 29. Gribble, Charles ... „ Auckland Education Board 30. Hardy, Charles J. ... „ Wellington Education Board 31. Hassing, George M. ... j „ Southland Education Board 32. Horan, Thomas" ... ., Native School Education Department 33. Howard, Charles C. ... „ Marlborough Education Board ... 34. Hughson, William" ... Janitor, Otago High School 35. Hutton, David C* ... Principal, Otago School of Art Education Board ... | 36. Ingpen, Edward L. ... Teacher, Wangatiui Education Board 37. Johnston, Robert ... „ Wellington Education Board 3SS. Jones, Thomas A. ... „ Auckland Education Board 39. Kilburn, Joseph ... ,. Southland Education Board 40. Lee, Wesley ... ... „ Auckland Education Board 41. Lothian, John ... „. „ 42. Lyttle, John*... ... „ Southland Education Board 48. Macan, George H.* 44. Macbeth, James J. ... Clerk, North Canterbury Education Board 45. McDonald, Kenneth ... Teacher, Southland Education Boanl 46. McFarlane, Peter G. M. „ North Canterbury Education Board 47. Mclntosh, Alexander" ... „ Auckland Education Board 48. Maddison, John ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 49. Matthews, Ernest W. D. „ Native school 50. Menzies, George ... Teacher, Otago Education Board 51. Milne, William 52. Moores, Peter ... „ Auckland Education Board 53. Mulhern, John ... „ Native school 54. Murdoch, James ... „ Southland Education Board 55. Nicholls, Alfred ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 56. Peterson, William ... „ Southland Education Board 57. Pole, Richard P. ... ! „ North Canterbury Education Board 58. Porritt, Thomas, Rev. ... „ Wellington Education Board 59. Reid, James ... ... „ Otago Education Board 60. Schmidt, Peter E. ... Architect to North Canterbury Education Board ... 61. Scholes, Abraham ... Teacher, North Canterbury Education Board 62. Scott, James ... ... „ South Canterbury Education Board 63. Sloman, John F. ... „ Auckland Grammar School Board 64. Smith, John ... .. Secretary to Marlborough High School, Secretary to Marlborough Education Board 65. Stewart, Alexander ... Teacher, Otago Education Board 66. Stewart, Washington S. „ Wanganui Education Board 67. Taylor, William N. ... „ North Canterbury Education Board 68. Tobin, William H. J.*| „ Education Department... 69. Ward, Joseph ... „ Marlborough Education Board ... 70. Ward, William ... „ South Canterbury Education Board 71. Wood, John*.. ... 72. Young, Henry ... „ Native school... £ s. a. 101 10 0 118 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 106 0 0 52 0 0 77 15 4 52 0 0 52 0 0 68 8 2 52 0 0 207 4 5 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 75 13 1 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 62 10 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 85 4 5 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 56 5 9 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 89 0 11 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 87 8 6 78 19 10 88 6 0 55 9 8 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 138 16 0 52 0 0 Total ... ... ... < 4,696 2 10 4,696 2 10 Females. — 1. Anderson, Barbara C. ... Teacher, Auckland Education Board 2. Anderson, Elizabeth ... „ Native school... 3. Barton, Annie, Mrs. ... „ Auckland Education Board 4. Batten, Annie E. ... „ Westland Education Board 5. Beale, Arundel M. ... j „ Auckland Education Board 6. Beattie, Jane, Mrs. ... „ Native school... 7. Blades, Bithiah* ... „ Auckland Grammar School 8. Blyth, Sarah F. ... i „ Wanganui Education Board 9. Bullock, Julia W., Mrs. I „ North Canterbury Education Board 10. Christie, Catherine W. ... J „ Native school... 11. Dement, Mary A. ... „ Nelson Education Board 12. Dunning, Eliza L. ... „ Auckland Education Board 13. Francis, 0. A., Mre. ... „ Wellington Education Board 14. Goulding, Jane E. „ Auckland Education Board 15. Greensill, Susan M., Mrs. „ Native school... 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 71 7 9 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 * Allowances gran t Allowanoe granti ted duiing the period from 1st January to 31st December, 1909. ad under section 235 (2) of the Education Act, 1908.

9

E.—9

(c.) Return of Persons in Receipt of Annual Allowances —continued. (i.) Allowances granted to Contributors who reached the Retiring-age— continued.

(ii.) Allowances granted to Contributors medically unfit for Further Duty.

2 -E. 9.

Name. Occupation. Annual Bate of Allowance. Females —continued. 16. Haig, Catherine* 17. Haughton, S. E. J., Mrs. 18. Haultain, Frances A. ... 19. Heney, Annie, Mrs.* ... 20. Henry, Margaret 21. Hoey, J. N., Mrs. 22. Hopper, Mary E.* 23. Huie, Marjory S.* 24. Hyatt, Alice S. 25. Johnson, Susan H.* 26. Kitchingman, Eliza 27. Lissaman, M. H.,Mrs 28. Longmore, Frances 29. McGavin, Jessie, Mrs.... 30. Mackay, Ida O. 31. Moller, Louisa A. 32. Paterson, Jane* 33. Peake, Sarah N., Mrs.... 34. Phillips, Mary, Mrs. ... 35. Plummer, Mary, Mrs. ... 36. Eitchie, Christian, Mrs. 37. Simpson, M. E., Mrs. ... 38. Stevens, Dora S., Mrs.... 39. Stewart, Jessie 40. Taylor, Mary 41. Tennent, M. I., Mrs. ... 42. Tregear, Mary K., Mrs. 43. Wakelin, Ellen A., Mrs.* 44. Will, Louisa M. 45. Wilson, Jane* 46. Wimperis, Frances M 47. Woodward, Laura, Mrs. 48. Wraytt, Christina, Mrs. Teacher, Otago Education Board „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Native school .. „ Auckland Education Board „ Wanganui Education Board „ Auckland Education Board „ Otago Education Board „ Auckland Education Board „ Native school... „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Auckland Education Board „ Native school... „ Westland Education Board „ Nelson Education Board „ Otago Education Board „ Marlborough Education Board ... „ Auckland Education Board £ s. d. 104 3 4 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 80 18 0 56 19 9 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 70 10 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 */ it a • » • ••• „ South Canterbury Education Board „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Otago Education Board „ Industrial school „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Native school „ Auckland Education Board Cookery Instructress, Wellington Education Board... Teacher, Otago Education Board „ Otago Girls' High School „ Auckland Education Board „ Southland Education Board Total £2,620 4 10 Grand total. ... 20 £7,316 7 8 * Allowances gri in ted during the leriod from 1st January to 31st December, 1909.

Name. Occupation. Annual Rate of Allowance. Mates. 1. Baragwanath, John ... 2. Bussell, Henry 3. Dalby, John B. 4. Feist" Adolph M.* ... 5. Harrison, Thomas C. 6. Marr, Thomas M. ... 7. Marshall, Leslie C.*... 8. Mason, Herbert 9. Smith, John H.*+ ... .0. Warren, Francis* Teacher, South Canterbury Education Board „ North Canterbury Education Board it it a „ Wellington Education Board „ Otago Education Board ... „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Auckland Education Board £ s. a. 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 98 2 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 75 3 0 80 17 10 111 15 4 „ Christchurch Boys' High School „ Auckland Education Board Females. 1. Albert, Sarah E. 2. Boulcott, Henrietta... 3. McKay, Elizabeth ... 4. Osmers, M. B., Mrs. 5. Paul, Susan B. 6. Peat, Janet H., Mrs. 7. Ray, Josephine 8. Rowley, Jane G. Teacher, Otago High School Board „ Wellington Education Board „ Otago Education Board ... „ Westland Education Board „ Otago Education Boord ... „ Wanganui Education Board „ Auckland Education Board „ South Canterbury Education Board 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 52 0 0 .8 Total ... £1,093 18 2 ;; Allowances granted durii ig the period lot January to 31st December, 1909. f Died 31st October, 1U09.

E.—9

10

(iii.) Allowances granted to Widows of Deceased Contributors.

(iv.) Allowances granted to Children of Deceased Contributors and Annuitants.

Wiaows. Occupation of Deceased Contributor. Annual Bate of Allowance. 1. Adams, Annie, Mrs.* ... 2. Baldwin, Mary A., Mrs.* 3. Bennett, Mary R., Mrs. Teacher, Thames High School Board „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Otago Education Board £ a. d. 18 0 0 18 0 0 j is o a I 5 4 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 4. Berry, Alice M., Mrs. ... 5. Bramley, Charlotte, Mrs. 6. Brownlee, Lilian G., Mrs. 7. Closs, Jane, Mrs.* 8. Broughton, Esther, Mrs.* 9. Crummy, Sarah, Mrs. ... .0. Dawson, Annie, Mrs. ... .1. Duthie, Grace, Mrs. .2. Ellis, Elizabeth, Mrs. ... .3. Evans, Margaret A. T., Mrs.* .4. Fannin, Martha, Mrs. ... .5. Ferguson, Elizabeth, Mrs. .6. Gloy, Margaret, Mrs. ... .7. Golding, Mary E., Mrs... .8. Greenwood, Margaret, Mrs. .9. Hailey, Elizabeth, Mrs. !0. Hutchinson, Margaret G., Mrs.* „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Marlborough Education Board ... „ Otago Education Board „ Native school ... Clerk to Board, Canterbury College Teacher, Wanganui Education Board „ Native school ... Secretary to Nelson Education Board Teacher, Taranaki Education Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Otago Education Board „ Native school ... 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 if it • • • • • • • • • „ Southland Education Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 11. Ingpen, Emily B., Mrs. 12. Kerr, Catherine S., Mrs. 13. Lindsay, Lillias, Mrs* ... 14. Maber, Grace, Mrs. 15. McClelland, Elizabeth, Mrs. !6. McKinnon, Grace, Mrs. !7. Marshall, Eliza F., Mrs.* 18. Mason, Margaret H. E., Mrs.* 19. Neill, Susan, Mrs.* 10. Patrick, Mary J., Mrs.... 11. Potts, Eosarnond, Mrs.... !2. Rowe, Jemima J. M.,Mrs. S3. Selby, Emma, Mrs. 14. Sigley, Lillie C, Mrs. ... !5. Tegner, Clara, Mrs. !6. Walter, Eosa A., Mrs. ... !7. Watt, Elizabeth, Mrs. ... 18. Webber, Mary E., Mrs. „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ North Canterbury Education Board „ Otago Education Board „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Otago Education Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 „ Southland High School Board „ Otago Education Board „ Wellington Education Board 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Native school ... „ Taranaki Education Board „ Southland Education Board ti it a • • • „ Native school ... „ Wanganui Education Board „ Native school ... „ Auckland Education Board „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 18 0 0 Total £689 4 0

Name. Occupation of Contributor. Annual Bate of Allowance. Males. 1. Braniley, Clifford E. ... 2. Brownlee, John K.* 3. Clarkson, Bernard T.* ... 4. Evans, Eoss* 5. Evans, James L.* 6. Evans, William T.* ... 7. Evans, Harry M.* 8. Evans, Colin M.* 9. Evans, Jack* .0. McKinnon, Hugh L. ... .1. McKinnon, John C. .2. Eowe, Douglas E. .8. Sigley, Edgar .4. Sigley, Harry S. 5. Watt, Alan M. Teacher, North Canterbury Education Board „ Marlborough Education Board ... „ Wanganui Education Board „ Taranaki Education Board // it n * • ■ n ir n it a a ... £ 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 // // // a a a ... „ Southland High School Board it a it • • • „ Southland Education Board „ Native school ... « « • • ■ ... ... Architect to Auckland Education Board ... • Allowances gn rated during period from 1st January to 31st December, 1909.

11

E.—9,

(iv.) Allowances granted to Children of Deceased Contributors and Annuitants— continued.

Teachers' Superannuation Fund. Revenue Account. & a. d. £ s. d. To Balance 31st Deoember, 1908 .. 84,471 7 1 By Allowanoes .. .. .. 8,754 1 9 Contributions .. .. .. 35,121 11 1 Contributions refunded .. .. 1,775 14 1 Government subsidy .. .. 7,000 0 0 Commission .. .. .. 405 14 4 Interest .. .. .. .. 4,751 9 7 Balance .. .. .. .. 120,408 17 7 £131,344 7 9 £131,344 7 9 Balance-sheet. £ s. d. £ a. d. Fund ac per Revenue Account .. .. 120,408 17 7 In hands of Public Trustee for investment 118,615 9 1 Retiring-allowances in transit .. .. 58 14 5 Contributions in transit .. .. 353 5 5 Commission acorued .. 199 18 7 Interest acorued .. .. .. 1,710 4 1 Suspense Account (contributions overpaid) 11 8 0 £120,678 18 7 £120,678 18 7 E. O. GIBBES, Secretary for Education. F. K. de Castbo, Chief Clerk and Accountant, and Secretary to Teachers' Superannuation Board. Examined and found correct.—Robert J. Collins, Controller 18th June, 1910." The amount in hands of the Public Trustee for investment is £118,615. Of this sum £113,250 has been invested on mortgage—£72,2so at 5 per cent., and £41,000 at 4J per cent. The balance, £5,365, bearing interest at 4 per cent., is awaiting investment. Geo. Fowlds, Chairman of the Board. Approximate Coat of Paper.— Preparation, not given ; printing (4,900 copies), £16 15e.

By Authority : John Mackay, Government Printer, Wellington.-^l9lO.

Price-6d.~\

Name. Occupation of Contributor. Annual Bate of Allowance. Females. 1. Bennett, Dorothy V. ... 2. Berry, Dorothy M. 3. Bramley, Gladys V. ... 4. Bramley, Daisy B. 5. Bramley, Winifred M. ... 6. Broughton, Esther P. N.* 7. Broughton, Helen S. E.* 8. Broughton, Janet G. M.* 9. Brownlee, Gwendolen A.* 10. Clarkson, Bosina" 11. Clarkson, Mary L.* 12. Clarkson, Estelle Q* ... 13. Evans, Madge M. :;: 14. Gloy, OlgaH. M. 15. Hutchinson, M. M. M.* 16. Hutehinson, Kathleen M. B.* 17. Maber, Kathleen E. ... 18. Marshall, Zealanda* ... 19. Marshall, Eliza F. S.* ... 20. Potts, Lillian J. 21. Sigley, Hattie E.. 22. Sigley, Joyce E. 23. Sigley, Hazel M. 24. Sigley, Ethel G. 25. Webber, Mina H. 0. ... Teacher, Otago Education Board „ North Canterbury Education Board it if a > . • n a if „ Native school ... ,i i, ... ... ... a it • • • • • • • • • „ Marlborough Education Board ., Wanganui Education Board a a a ... // a it • • • „ Taranaki Education Board „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Southland Education Board a it a ••• £ 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... „ Otago Education Board... « // a * • „ Taranaki Education Board „ Native school ... a it • • • • • • * • • ;/ // '.. ■ • • •.. II it ... •*• • •» „ Hawke's Bay Education Board ... ... 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 13 40 Total ... £520 * Allowances g: ranted during pariod from 1st January to 31st Deoember, 1909.