mare I examined could be the dam of the horse in dispute. Mr. Pelichet's mare has had 4 foals to my knowledge. I do not know whether she has had a fifth, as I have not seen the mare this year. The second foal she had is the horse in dispute. The first foal is now running on my Run. "I saw the mare which the natives allege to be the mother of the horse in dispute two years since running at Wautukai. She had then no foal running at her side. At the time I saw her she had had a foal cut away from her but a few weeks before. She was much disfigured." (Signed) Edward Collins. Sworn before me this 21st. day of October 1856. (Signed) Alfred Domett, R.M.