MR KENRICK REPLY TO MR WHALL.
(To tip Edi^rf the- 6^.y. Him- $L*gittoSiR/i- Howler contemppble' I Jnaj| *^ in % Mr WliallVJfode of conHSc&ng a dlsoitssion *' on a pniSSpMujMtioii, and though I do feel the cbntest-liltween us to bo. manijestly un- '. ."|e.qia.aLwhen_ the_chpsen •wfapons^areoalumux, I and slander — (for who can compete with Mr Whall at /those weapons'?)— l cannot let bis false assertions go forth to the public tmcon.T tradioted. - -In- answer Mr ... W-hairs . reiterated assertion that Mr Revell and I were seen byj himself and others iii the Court House spinning a coin for the choice of sections in this -towiij after some gentlemen had 1 been informed that there were no more sections to be taken up-^to this and to, any othei assertion of Mr Whall's 'which charges Mi iJevell and.me.wiyi qqiripetingfor<wi// secliom in the town of Greynouth, Maori' 'town included, to the.disa^l vantage of.the public,, X; say deliberately, si£ that Mr Whall asserts, for purposes of.|»g own, what he knows to lie false ; and I say more, sir, that if Mr Wliall believes what he has asserted, he has been guilty, as a publjo man, in not bringing ,^o, matter before the public before, 'and for concealing it in his own breast for come 13 months. ; Mr IJoyell's explanation , .of pur having tossed for- choice of two sections at Okarita, in the presence of Mr Mackay* $ , literally true/ and' we both hold the sections ' ■bill, ya't/sr havinp^d twelye month^ rent oh them. If Mr Coates, or any" other gentlemen, back up; Mr WhalV in 'his assertion, let. them,: come forward and make their statements, Now, sir, with respect to the much vexed question of the piece of land I hold from the Maoris, Mr Whall hajr again spoken iuoorrectly, when lie says Jhat, I received that land in preference to some of the public who were desirous of leasing it some months prior to my taking- possession; The contrary is the fact--for part of the very land I Jioltl was appljed for.; and .taken \ip, and ;after- ; wards thrown up as worth'le^s, being pribr; to my applying for it. Had I wished to speculate in sections '-1. had- the choice of the- whole of the Maori land as well as the rest of the public; Jtmt'l refraiiie'd.'.aud only asked/Mr Mackay for a piece to build upon for myself. That this , land subsequently became more i valuable is surely not 'my fhult, cspeoially as lam paying 'a rent quite up to the average ■for it.-. •■ ; .■•■ . : ,^-:-ki-^\- ' ■"•.■-. | Tedious as I must necessarily.- appear, 'sir,- 1 there is- yet another,, matter to icnich upon, and did I not feel} sir, that the whole of my couduct in the whole of the affair I allude to was/not only blameless .but I d^rb to say, commendable, it woulif lie" with 'far different feelings that I should approach the subject, -for it is a heavy, nay, the heaviest charge that can.be made against any jnaii-rAthnt. ofoppressing the widow and robbing the helpless— and. one that ought not lightly to be hia:le. Mr Whall has published a letter signed by -one. Jessie Oak, accusing me of robbing her of a section in this tinyi\ and of doing it in a mariner, which/ if true; ought to draw upon me the indignation of all honest' men.^ I will make a plain statfihent of the facts of the case, sir, , then. Jet,. the public judge whether I am 1 more 'sinned ajiainst than sinning. . Spme;|S, : inonths or so,. I, was. requested by the i friends' of the' late Mr OAk,' cai-penter, to endeavor to get him' some work atyie-Grey, he being then in Hokitik.-r, and very badly off. I spoke to Mr Henry Jones, caipenter,-oftthiß town,? who kindly promised j liini Avoik. Mr Ooks came up and. worked . for some time with Mx. J.ones. H|s wife Jessie Oajcs s^J/seiiutntly oame.tp Greympiith to join him. ' At 'the ;tiiniE>vrtf: her arrival,; both Jones and Oaks >vere' innng 'in a cottage in CTresson.str^ct,, qii the, very si^c.oij which the Ileli^dus "liistitnie = iif.w' sfatids:' 5 T!h\s cottage ■''belonged ' -'to ife.esrs 'Hawkips ■ dnil': Stroiifc£ 6f Hi»kir|lta r and, (iliristcliurol); -Mr ; Hjiwkesliih'ing'n'o acquaintance, ontheOrey ! but myself (or TprcßHine so) had aslced nic" to look after' the ; cbttagc: and 'see itkept in repair; ; l^inay s^^Kat'h'c'h^l'oiily'erecW' the cottage to keep possession of the business site, (his original intention being: to creitt d store there. )' Oaks arrived T told her lmsband he ■niightil.ave the -coita^e Vent free, merely for keeping it in «ood order. He' (OakeS) livedi'there till his-'death. ■' ■ \ few days subsequent •#> r ; tlin^ ; cv;ent,l,.was :inf<irmed by.' Mr Jones 'that the widow, Mrs Oakes, had put piles' into 1 the •groiiml, with the intention >of lnulding inj "fi-oiitrj pf the cottage, and thereby claiming the secitiohs.' lof course sent her- word' (as' she correctly states by Mr Planagani a' policeman, but who liyed next; door to her) that she must, leave the house, for I. looked; upon the affair? as a §reat piece of on Oiikes^' part," after Baying been allowed to; ■occupy the : house so long rent free. V M s. Oakes^ as she' says, came to the Court ;Ho'use ito Vcgister the' section., ■■■ I need not : point' but to yoiir;' sir,' iihafr according W^the iGold Kelclsylle/iula-v tions this'conrd'no^'iiv'aiiy^-'fcMe^avißM/eeri 1 done, theie being a' hpnse already on the section. --And I 1 think it alinos't as needless^ forane to say that I did not aiis-.ver as slie^ describes, those, who kno-yv my, corflpe't; in the office caii judge on that point. ' 'Mrs Oakes refusing to leave the i house,' I' did take out a summcuis, -iii Mr. Hawkes' nam.e andr.by his authority, for Lo; .the amount oi: one ; week'.s rent "^,;and !L Aid f .'tell^ili QJiaili^ to.- say^tVj . s Mrs , Oakes, when .serving' the sunun^ns,^a^ if '' ,she f3iose to leave'tthe •, li'o'Ks^ and jpay r l;he costs of the summons, -Tirould withdraw the case . Sh£ did bo,th, and lof coiu'se' let the affair drop. "- ' '■■"■ ■':'[''' - v "" '■'"** *i x V'" . Tliis,sir, is^the,, whole' triith, as, plenty in this town can' testify • ' let' ; tlie public jiiH^e" 'l)etween. this , woman , arfd I-.-.. . I, hayc^only f ll rtlie'r^ to -remark;, ■ ; aV,'a VsQmeM^at r ~eofaorr 'dinary thing, •; that' '^tr'Wh\li 'cannot <r eve,ii" bringso simple, an affair as this before the public^ without distorting^ factsi '-i Mr- Whall! says that this woman :,was (>I; quote his own* words) "ejected .bx.a ; ; bailiflt from a.section which was'a.ftenvards' solf|?at"tiie land sale 4 , without improvements, at the'upset price, and charged 5s for^suin'mOns^iiid tfcsts, jntithout |an order t9.. pay it." .-, , r ln; .answer, l^say .the SwOmanwa§not ejected l>y a. ; bailiff, and theland was not sold at the upset price, ...without,' improvements, for Mr - Goates (I .belieye) acting for tihe.triistees purchase^ the ground for the Religious' Ihstifcu^" J after .'.paying Messrs^ s Ha ivkes ,an,d-"Stfxiuts soino' : TtWoM for iiriproyetAerits'. 1 • l Mr •"06aies Will ■correct* me if .lam wrong.' j '■'' : - ~ : ■':'■ ■'■ ><* ' : -'- '■']-■''' '■■'■'■ ' :) .' :J In' cphclitsion?^ as F havevno wish tcPIVe 1 .: .always- jtrowbling you, or to liave'my uiime continually Vdragged -public. 'fe : gratify 'the privatrt' malfce' "df - any 'man/'- 1; have : to inform Mr WhalLthat I-':liave-itlapeil''liia"' letter in the'iiands' ';'pf^ hiy solid tor; ; with instructions to commence an action agaiis!; Mr WhjUJ, ilhe-shoulfLthin^ tUere are^suJflScyaitV growncls to justify me in incurring the expense, and this is' thfi mode^ I intend to auswer any further personal attacks of Mr shall always be ready to argiieTto the best' of" my ability, and Bince:myjJjnpi«ZeHcc// in ipffering to discuss a "question so vitally* important to this town as tjjatpf a municipality, "with the aid of men of ability, has it appears 'somewhat fi'jghTiene.d Mr Whall,; I rencj^t '• th>, offer; and without any extraneons?aid ' what-.jeyer.will.-argu.O;; th,e queslji,ou •^}/h;hinA)on its merits, and let the public be the jiidge between us, merely premising that personal abuse is i no argument, and a th,at were I the :scoiuicifel Mr Whatf hasfend«avdredteTnake' mfe;«ut, it would. not^ affect. the question at issue— muiiicipi&ty^ 'least^,. •■..;.- ■':" .'.'.; , .y. ■':;■. .',;')):'};■ ,'■■;' y-'s ■■? L '\';.■.- iA'poHgising *for" ' the- 'raayoidabls- feng^h"^ ' this letter.— I am, &c., - March 0,/1567.
Permanent link to this item
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/GRA18670307.2.7
Bibliographic details
Grey River Argus, Volume III, Issue 180, 7 March 1867, Page 2
Word Count
1,327MR KENRICK REPLY TO MR WHALL. Grey River Argus, Volume III, Issue 180, 7 March 1867, Page 2
Using This Item
No known copyright (New Zealand)
To the best of the National Library of New Zealand’s knowledge, under New Zealand law, there is no copyright in this item in New Zealand.
You can copy this item, share it, and post it on a blog or website. It can be modified, remixed and built upon. It can be used commercially. If reproducing this item, it is helpful to include the source.
For further information please refer to the Copyright guide.