THE JUBILEE HOME.
DISCUSSION AT THE BOBOTOH COUNCIL. . .
The Management of the Jubliee-Home came in for a littlo criticism at the Borough Council meeting/ last evening. Tie • question was introduced in consequence of the Mayor reporting that he had given permission, subject to the approval of the Council, for the ereotion of l a cottage on the Borough reserve, near the Cemetery, for a family in distressed circumstances in Wanganui, the money for which had been raised by subscription. * Cr Peat intimated Ma intention of objecting to the action of the Mayor, v Cr Richardson, while sympathising with the Mayor in hia efforts to assist a , deserving case, thought the Council - might err in establishing a precedent. Cr Bell pointed out that they, already' bad a precedent for such a step, in that -7* the Council had allowed "Granny" Dalton to occupy ft piece of a borough re- ■■ servo, and ho had never heard any ono raise an objection to this. Cr Perrett said he was fully in sympathy with the Mayor in helping an un- , fortunate family, and thought no great harm would result in the Council allow- ~ ing them to occupy the land. Cr Liffiton said he had no objection, provided a document was drawn up Betting foith that the occupants had no* vested interests in the property. He pointed out that in the past the Council lad had a great deal of difficulty in get- ' ting rid of persons who lived on the reaeivea now known, as Queen's. Park and ' Cook's Gardens. Cr Bassott expressed sympathy with the unfortunate people for whom the\\ Uxtney was raised, and commended the-, actions of those moving in the matter. * - He thought it was most unfortunate that ' they had iv the town, an institution, specially established to provide for such cs?es, m such a state that people of tins • sort were practically excluded from' it. - He did not undertake to criticise the ' gentlemen who had the control of dt; but , there was the fact that the public gener- '' ally were dissatisfied with the conduct of - it, as also the old people themselves.* Ifwas a lamentable state of affairs that ' they could not send the family to th&-',-Home and make them comfortable. With retpect to the erection of the cottage, he » as not so much afraid of establishing" a precedent, as ho wai desirous of guarding the Avenue to the Hospital. The locality between the town and the 1 Heads ' was fast being built on, and he thought; that in time the Borough reserves would^ be taken up for residential sites-. , .J. The Mayor stated that hq' had' no dcubt tho cottage Mould not be unsightly and might be erected back from the read. - ' Cr Gatenby, speaking as one of tho • Council's representatives on the Charit- - able Aid Board, said he took exception ,' to the statement of Cr Bussett, that the* inmates of the Old Men's Home wete ( diß^> satisfied. The statement was absolutely,^ without foundation. He went up to'therp Home the other day in company with Mr't Johnston, another member of the Board; s; Tho latter had gone up not officially,' but '• as a friend of his (Cr Gatenby's), TheyV spent nearly two hours 'up there^-andA found the bods were clean anchamply / supplied with clothing. They questioned-, every inmate in the place as to' wHettiej; ' ' they were satisfied, but only one had the % slightest complaint to make, and that ~-, wan had been criticised by the editor o£ '' the "Herald" as a man who was not to be believed on oath. Further ,than that'he ■ (Cr Gatenby) had the unsolicited' testi;' ' mony of a gentleman' who was intimate * with a number of old soldiers up at,tnew. Home who formerly were connected ,wi£h.- "; the Bame regiment ac his informant, 'andri he always made it a point to inqmro. aa to their welfare at the Home. HoffidJ* ifc gave him groat pleasure v . tp aes.'tle^ clean and decent way the mea, Vere 1 ? dressed, when, they came to town., !!«s£-' one and all stated tiiat they were'treated-" in the most admirable manner, and had , not the slightest reason to «fay"anythingagainst the institution. There had. been \, a great deal in the papers, bufho^Cr' Gatenby) had thoroughly satisfied hMv! self that the complaints were, entirely*; groundless. One of 'th<? ininates- > vwis v &t '.' the bottom of all the trouble v ■ This/nw^ went to one of the newspapers, and etafi?* ed that he had been, treated in'tK^Jfldlt I brutal manner, and to''the otW' paper' i he had vouchsafed the statement tht^t he ? was not badly treated at all; becauee'ihof officials at the Htfmo were frightened ti s " .treat him badly, and that he 'was /ably '- speaking on behalf of the other inmates?! He (Cr Gatenby) would be plegaed'atjniy j time to give an account of his steward-? ship and if the Council were dissatisfied ■£ with him they could appoint" another^ representative. '' ■v/r*^ Cr Liffiton, as tho other representative^ of tho Council on the Board, 'said; iho^ could le-echo what Cr Gatenby! had saidVf Ho had not been to the Home.rebently,^ but some little time ago he maae » ixoeb'ti eihaustiye inquiry (privately andVajStuS prise visit). One of his old servants was,4 at the Home, and he had expressed hints £, Belf perfectly satisfied.' The agitation in% the first place had been got up bfSitifofX two people who did not know Veil fthe> characters of those who gave" tKemiinps foimation. Like his colleagne,xlie l rwaß^;! always willing to give an aoqount/of'iiqS stewardship. He was on tho Board to.uijß^ hia common sense, and not merely as? '■£% deputy. He resented the inferences thatf'j other members of the Board we^e brute*.' s It was not his disposition to be cruel 'or- Ibrutal, and the gentlemen who were'as-'J sociated with him on the -Board had a ■. reputation for being patient and'reason- * able. , 0 ^-C. Cr Bassett said he 1 thought ifc:waa-' ! quitq possible that the Council's reprerV sentatives were quite honest' and. sincere • in their convictions, but at the. Santa's timp quite wrong. The" Council .Jfad'f. never characterised them as brutosV-Tng"? cpmion was, notwithstanding Cr, Gateir-4* d/s statement, that the men-'made;'iioj> complaints, that thsy wefe afraid-to'dob so. The old men looked on'the'offlcialst! at the Home as fixtures and asVoonSa lquenne were absolutely afraid of.jntitt-;* man treatment. Some of "them had' Said they would suffer if they made com-* plaints— that was the position '■ that '• many of tho old men occupied.' He •had, been informed by a gentleman, CwKo"se-~ statements he had no reason to ,ddUht,4? that the ivardsman at the Homo h'ad'aefeV ed more like a brute than a man—He (CjA Bassett) was positively ashamed 'to- w-' 1 peat the words that had been, applied to'i some of the inmates by the warder.- .'lf. the statements which he had heard '(h"e could not vouch for the truth of them, l but they had been made to bim'bya'c gentleman whd heard them usc&'iiijsi-, self) had been made, then the mac'^aa"-' not fib to occupy the position of 'warder/ and it was to be deplored that old \> people's lives should be made miserable^ as they were at tho present timei'-'Ono'*. man was refused assistance in gettfeVtip^ the staircase, and other inmates -%ad">' been told they ought to be dead. These 1 statements had come from a person who = heard them used. - it - ,-^:^ Cr Gatenby suggested that Cr Bassett,^ seeing that he seemed to have the nuifl'or '■> so much ot heart, should -visit the Honied and he felt sura that he (Cr - Bassett);' would then be of the same opinidnlaS'r himself — that tho inmates were happy '^ and contented. -" x " Cr Peat said that the discussion shifsrii ed most clearly tha£ the "Council werp» ; taking a wrong move. Any oneVof "thes inmates of the Home was just as muclrt entitled to apply for a similar concession^ as were .those who now aaked for "a sitai for the erection of a cottage. If the man-& agement of the Home was wrong 'i»? should be rectified. They should not " make fish of one and fowl uf .anotfcer,''Ib was the principle of the thing that ho' " objected to. It was kind of uhe people? to .subscribe tiie money, but the Councilswas there to administer for all, not for,! any particular party. Oute they estab-; lished a precedent they wonld have.ap- ' plication from all quarters. He moved * that the action of the Mayor be not con< firmed. y " Cr Gatenby second* d the motion,? asho did not think by endorsing the ' Mayor's aotion they would be pntting ' the reserves to a proper use. The Home was the proper place for the unfortunate family, and they would be well looked allor there. - The Mayor said he was much surprised , that Crs Peat aud Gatenby would thuf, support a vote of censure on his actioiis. I Crs. Peat and Gatenby— No' no ] He contended that it was practte- ' ally a vote of ceneure. He thought that in such a case they mitfht show a little of - the milk of human kindness. Crs. Peafc and Gatenby had tulcen a w.rped view ol the matter, aa no harm could possibly >>? dene by doing as he had 'su^estei II it -vas wrong to do as he proposed, it.' the Chess Club and one or two other
similar bodies. When they were told by }iioplc that (hoy would not put a dog in tbc Old Men's Home, bo>v could they expect others to beak a icf"?C there. He did not proles to k'le-w anything about Mio institution, but this he would say, that in an isointed home like that, where there wore onlj' two ofljceis, it was not a right principle that they bhould be Jiear relatives. [ V voice There arc throe attendants, all rotated. j Tlmt made tht principle trebly winug. As iar as the Council's reprea-ciitathes on the Boaiu were concerned, lio had contidence in them. Cr Peat— How would you get on if a man nud his wife m maged tho Horno 5 The Mayoi — That )& a different nialtci •altogether i Alter ;v little further discussiein, the Mayor's action waa confirmed. Crs. Gatenby and Peat ale.no opposing it.
Permanent link to this item
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/WH19000117.2.16
Bibliographic details
Wanganui Herald, Volume XXXIV, Issue 9940, 17 January 1900, Page 2
Word Count
1,682THE JUBILEE HOME. Wanganui Herald, Volume XXXIV, Issue 9940, 17 January 1900, Page 2
Using This Item
No known copyright (New Zealand)
To the best of the National Library of New Zealand’s knowledge, under New Zealand law, there is no copyright in this item in New Zealand.
You can copy this item, share it, and post it on a blog or website. It can be modified, remixed and built upon. It can be used commercially. If reproducing this item, it is helpful to include the source.
For further information please refer to the Copyright guide.