‘No’ to offer on Petrocorp
H|| I ' 'll' ' | ■': [ f i PA ! j.-i, I jWellington The Commerce Commissiph yesterday declined Brierley ; Investments application to take over ; Petrocorp.;] j Tine] Comihission said the decision might be: re- : gard&d of richdhmic { in- : terest [only, since {the Governnjent ihad :{[ decided earlier this rriqnth to {sell its controlling j shareholding ; [in iPetrocorp to : Fletcher Challenge. : j i{ :| {if Brierley[(BlL) owned Petrocorp, j it: would have controlled :i all j of] [the wholesale and 74 per cent of tie retail I sales of'gas in the country] the! commiss tin’s deputy chairman :| Mr Ba'rrie Tucker, said in a statement. ! : [ | In I addition 1 it would have owned ] tlie main I trunc distribution pipe-' line.! ij 1 Hi | : ! h' i I ■ [ Tt e Government [had indicated, [ iri . | general terns], its] intention to deregulate [the! gas industry- l| "| | II!' ' i I" i Brierley had argued { thosi' intentions were so indefinite they should not be tiken into 1 account and the decision] should 1 be made in the current clim-i ate of price: I control,! franchised :j retail preaS, and! stringent ‘[take or pay’?: contracts. I ;[ j; I j H iwever, ; Mr [ Tucker said j the :i commission’s . view was that the Governmerts intention to deregulate was clear! in prin- i ciple. ' I :! [[{ ,i [' .{::[''! ' Si nee the Brierley takeover of Petrocorp, if appro) e d, would! {probably last for a long time, itjwas inappropriate to I consider it in the light of conditions which were virtually jeer-i
tain to change in the short ' keTm/T|{|l H 'J 11-l!! | The commission concluded the [proposal would involve the strengthening of existing dominance as Brierley alrjeridy is dominant in thrbe retail 'gas I markets] an^! Petnocorp is i already, dominant [in I the: North Island gas transmission market rind j [sevejrai retail gas markets. { J] Since these markets were within [the samje] [industry, the | merger; would resiilt in a number of anticompetitive I effects,[*| Mr Tucker said.' i: || JI | | To offset ) these detriments, Brierley liad{ submitted the ] mergeir wbuld have a number of public benefits, including I the ownership of thej gas industry by a New [Zealand company and a large number of BILI shareholders.. | i |i’ '. [ U. |{ IJ Even iif I these claims were accepted, they cduld probably !be claimed equally ] as welL | by: Fletcher) Challenge, Mr Tucker sai<J. . |: !;[ |' 1 11 On balance the Commission found the merger, if implemented woluld [not .have produced benefits to the public | which would [outweigh the detriments arising from! a dominant position ini the gas marM- jI'JJ |l:'':|h I Although! the [decision might have; little practical effect because the i Government had' now] sold its shareholding! in Petrocorp to FletcherrChallenge, the analysis contained in; tlie . [decision sei [out the commission’s stance bn competition questions : which often arose in similar controversial mergers, IMr Tucker said. | F;; ;! I' < H I I ill ( I : i • -.1 ■ ! • i .i ' I .-■
Permanent link to this item
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/CHP19880323.2.150.5
Bibliographic details
Press, 23 March 1988, Page 35
Word Count
479‘No’ to offer on Petrocorp Press, 23 March 1988, Page 35
Using This Item
Stuff Ltd is the copyright owner for the Press. You can reproduce in-copyright material from this newspaper for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 3.0 New Zealand licence. This newspaper is not available for commercial use without the consent of Stuff Ltd. For advice on reproduction of out-of-copyright material from this newspaper, please refer to the Copyright guide.
Copyright in all Footrot Flats cartoons is owned by Diogenes Designs Ltd. The National Library has been granted permission to digitise these cartoons and make them available online as part of this digitised version of the Press. You can search, browse, and print Footrot Flats cartoons for research and personal study only. Permission must be obtained from Diogenes Designs Ltd for any other use.
Acknowledgements
This newspaper was digitised in partnership with Christchurch City Libraries.