PUBLIC EXAMINATION IN BANKRUPTCY.
Mr Suiter Before the Court
At the sitting of the Supreme Court in Banco, held this morning before Mr Juatic 6 Gillies, the matter of the: public examination of the. principals in the bankruptcy o W. J. Suiter and Co. came on. Mr Cave appeared for the Oificial Assignee, Dr. Me* Arthur for, Sutton. and .Co., creditors, and Mr Thoa. Cotter for the bankrupt. ■ '■_" The motion of the creditors asking for the public examination having been read, Mr W. J. Buiter^was duly sworn, and stated that the sworn sbabemeub as ;rea'ct was .made by him and was correct,* and that the minutes of the meeting in his estate as read was also correct. •""•'■*/ : The bankrupt was then examined by Dr. McArthur, when he sw!ore :^-;Mr Probheroe became my partner in May, 1886, >hen my business was in a flourishing condition. He put £1,500 into the business when he joined. I think my position at the bank waa very good then; there was a little debit balance, I think, some £200 odd. It was ab.ut £275 6s. On July 31st, two months after, as will be seen by my bank book, we had a ci'edib balance there of £16 2s 9d, It;; was within two or three months after Mr Protheroe joining that. I received the £1,500; the books will show for certain. His Honour: Has nob all this been already shown at the public meeting of the creditors, Dr. McArthur ?.: What is it that you want to show •?"■./ . Dr. McArthur: May it please your Honor, I wish to show that bnis money was received within the two months, and thac it has unaccountably been absorbed. : • ■..:;■ His Honor: The books will show that surely; and the statement should have been obtained at the first examination. Dr. McArthur: the bankrupt has never sworn that he received the money in lhab time, your Honor. ' , To Mr Suiter: I want you to state did you receive the money in the two months. Mr Suiter: I; admit to having received that mouey within the two months. Dr. McArthur: If your business was in such a flourishing condition as you state how is it that this £1,500 had, all been,ab- ;- sorbed within such a .short period ? What became of the money between May and July? ■ . ■■; .'■'.:/ :■ ;'''i '' ■' .• ' Mr Suiter t I have prepared a abatement here (pro uoing it) showing that my business at thetime was in a flourishing condition and showing my profits. As for, the expenditure of the £1,500, there was £276 debit balance at the; bank, £70 personal cash, £356 cash, £100 cash to Mrs Suiter,- £75 cash to the Kamo Hotel, £150 cash to another hotel, £100 to Suttori arid Co., £120 for a new copper and £368 for a new cbpperhbuse and cellar, This makes over £1600. I had a good well once, but Sutton and Co. sank one about 15 feet away on their/place and, ran it dry! anditcoatme£4otolay pipes» etc., to Mr; Seccombe's place and afterwards £100 for sinking another well. ~ Dr. McArthur.: Will you swear that this' moneyMwas spent withiri the two months? Mr Suiter: There or thereabouts. Dr. McArfchur: Are theßO items taken; but of the two months ? • ? Mr Suiter: I have not had my books to get them from. The items r are only roughones. •■■ ; ' '"■'■: ■•' -r1 - r : ' '■'- " ■:•'■ ''''7•' ' ' ■' ', .'' ' : His Honor: ,Is the £1,500 entered in the^ bookß as received ? F ; . _ Dr. McArthur: It is, your Honor. • .His Honor: Surely then the cash-book' Tfill show how the money was expended. Dr. McArthur: Yes,' your Honor, but tiio cash-book does nob show it in the wime way as the bankrupt now states. His Honor: What goMwulbhis examination do then, unless you ch^^^ items in the cash book t Dr. McArthur: Then y your Honor we will on}y take the explanation giveu by the cash book? '■ . .--,,•.: His Honor: Certainly* . ; Mr Suiter, examination continued :— Were ib agoodsbatnpl.would consider the bottled beer on :our premises :Jwhen > they were seized by: Sutton and C0.,b0 be fully.-. worth £1,000. But it.would go bad io %ho bottles, having been made with theVinferior malt supplied by Sutton'and Co. Could not say what the stock .was insured for. It would be aboub £750. ; f ;. .■: ; i - Here Hl3 Honor interposed and wished to know what that had to do with the matter. Dr. McArthur said he. wished to show thai the stock was a worthless ione> when His Honor said bhatthab 1 did nob mabter. The insurance was a floating one for a twelvemonth, and was nbton the stock at the '.time."'-.' -■ s .'■ ■'//"' . v v ' " ' "■" '■■;'• Examination continued •. I summoned a meeting of our creditors about the time I filed, and at the meeting wo made an oiler of 10& in the £. Mr Curtis, of Kaipara, and Mr Morrison Ayare at the meeting. Yes ; Mr Morrison was my: teller at the time. V^e were.prepared to make the offer of 10s in the £ ,'ab the time.,,, Our principal creiitors' did not attend the meeting. I let them know about the oiler indirectly. I never wrote to Sutbon&ndCb., who were my principal creditors; offering them 10s in the £, but I wrote asking, them to attend a meotiifg at which an offer would be madei; Ib is a further fact that if we had been allowed to carry on the business as we liked, arid to buy our malt where we liked j we \ could > have paid 20sin the£. The mare we had belonged to the firm, the buggy and harness'to my-pelf-'personally. J;-" so<d' them in' the mp,nbh t ot; April, or. about then, to Mr Stoymisori.'f I received;.;£lo,- but the bobal: amounb; was £42 10s. . The £3210s went bbwurds paying a privabe bill I owed Mr. Stevenson.! The sale was mac|eaboufc: April and may,nob have been e'nterefruritil June. .Ib was a private eale as ,the mare- was only worth. £3.:" The entering of-the bale in; the firm's book-was a mistake of the clerk's. The Mr Sievenson I ; aold the. turnout to was; a gentleman residing in Newton Road. ■ I see by the papers that he has since become bankrupt.* On the night of June I2th,wh;eu the seizure of our, brewery was made by Stttton and Co. I did nob remove a drop of beer to bhe Carlton Club Hotel, nor to the Bottling Company nor to any hotel. ; : Dr. McArthur.: iThisisdecidedlyiOpposite to what he said before, yoar Honor,; ■ Mr Suiter: Ypu said diHtinctly the night of the 12th June. .■ ~ v '.:. • . Dr. McArthur : Well did you remove any on the morning of that day ? Mr Suitor :" Yen, on tlio morning after Sutton and Co. h;ii entered inUjposscnsiou I removed beer inio the lilaces mentioned. I locked up the bailiff so as to take this beer away. In- Baying ;bhafc | may say bhi3.; There was some ; beerj ordered by some ; of our customers. The-beer-was in the carb' when SntbOn and Co. pufa the bailif! ihj and they prdefed ib to be taken down.; This was contrary to an arrangement I had made with Mr Sutton in Dr McArbhur'.s office that the business was to be carried bn as usual. Dr. McArfchur :v As my ; nam.e;lias been introduced I may say that no such, arrangement was made in my office." It was disI tin c.tly said that no such arrangement could be made. .■ " * ' ■ ■ Mr Suiter : That waa afterwards." I did make the arrangement^ with MV, Sutton and in your office too.; ... . Examination- continued: At the time Subbon and Company went" into/ possession of the brewery 1 owned the Carlbon, Club Hotel.; There was £2,000 on mortgage to the CharHiable:Aid' Board.* aiThere was''besidea £300 to Mr Osmond and another £500 secured by promise but not by' deed. I sold this hotel to Mrr Griffiths .for '£3,650." His Honor ■■:■^ Has pot all bhis information been obtained bofova ?. 13^*f^i*^'Tir'!Srfe. "**trr.. ■ . -.■«■>. f
Mr Cave and Mr Cotter: Every word of it,yourHonor , :; , , ~ His Honor: What is the use of wasting; time like this then, Dr. McArthur? Dr. McAtthur: Weli, your Honor; what steps can we take? His Honor: IS'obhing can; be done. Do you-wish bo;bring the case junder the summary clauses? ' , , , Dr. McArthur intimated that such was his intention. "'■'.,' .■ ■','-; His Honor: Well, Dr. McArthur, I have repeatedly laid it down ; a3;a hard and^tast rule that I shall never act under these clauses unless notice has been given bo bhe debtor thabihe is to be charged with certain specific acts of fraud. '" - ' Dr McArthur considered that the course he had adopted was' the correct one. to pursue. He said, in reply to His Honor,, tliat;he;did'not wish ;to make any charge His Honor pointed out j, that anybhing sworn to by the bankrupt would riot be evidence, and that the proper course >vas to go on the .evidence taken jbeforb. bhe. Onicial Assignee. ' .■ ;' :: ■ . ' ''. ■ , ■' Mr Cave suggested adjourning bhe examination. Dr. McArthur said that would suit; him. Mr Suiter : I would like to say, in refer-. ence to this, your Honor, thab I have been kept waiting about for three months wer this. I have (iiven up everything,: and^am practically without a penny, aad cannot go anywhere bo gain a Hying. . Mr Cotter said that Dr. McArthur might give notice to-morrow of the speeihc charges he wißhed. to bring against Suiter and Co.,and the public examination might proceed next Monday. Hi^ Honor consenting, Dr. McArthur agreed to this, so the examination was adjourned accordingly, His Honor intimating thab unless notice of bhe churges was given to-morrow the sibbing would be merely a matter of form. , '
Permanent link to this item
https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/AS18880917.2.52
Bibliographic details
Auckland Star, Volume XIX, Issue 219, 17 September 1888, Page 8
Word Count
1,577PUBLIC EXAMINATION IN BANKRUPTCY. Auckland Star, Volume XIX, Issue 219, 17 September 1888, Page 8
Using This Item
No known copyright (New Zealand)
To the best of the National Library of New Zealand’s knowledge, under New Zealand law, there is no copyright in this item in New Zealand.
You can copy this item, share it, and post it on a blog or website. It can be modified, remixed and built upon. It can be used commercially. If reproducing this item, it is helpful to include the source.
For further information please refer to the Copyright guide.
Acknowledgements
This newspaper was digitised in partnership with Auckland Libraries.