BEFF TRUST OPERATIONS.
TO THE EDITOR. Fir.—Tlif' futility of the ComraomvraUh Act as a means to repress trusts lias been demonstrated over and over again. The findings of the Royal Commission appointed by the t '-ommonweiiith Govern - jneiit into the alleged operations of the American Beef Tiust in Australia arc of a very negative character. •• No evidence of combines, bit careful watch recommended," is tho crux of their decisions.
I do not mean to infer that trust legislation in Australia has been absolutely useless j but, confronted with a trust m the full vigor and plentitude of its power, it bus on moro than one occasion been absolutely futile. It has resembled the action of trying with a straw to divert a cataract. Thorn are. of course, many difficulties in the administration of an Anti-truets Act . There is the distinction between combination:-, and co-operative effort on the part of manufacturers and producers, etc., which are the inevitable result of existing conditions, and if prohibited would create a condition of commercial and industrial chaos, and those combines formed for the
avowed purpose of controlling prices, of preventing all competition, not only amongst these combining, but also preventing all competition by outsiders by a system of boycott. The former is a justifiable process while the competitive system exists, the latter a noxious, illegitimate, monopolistic, selfish monster, that requires rigorc*.-, and adequate control, ec as to prevent it injuring the public or existing in such form as to inevitably threaten such injurs'. By that we cun gauge somewhat the import of those words contained in the Commission's report- “ careful watch recommended.”—l am, etc., W. E. J. Maguibk. December 29.
Permanent link to this item
BEFF TRUST OPERATIONS., Evening Star, Issue 15687, 29 December 1914
BEFF TRUST OPERATIONS. Evening Star, Issue 15687, 29 December 1914
Using This Item
Allied Press Ltd is the copyright owner for the Evening Star. You can reproduce in-copyright material from this newspaper for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons New Zealand BY-NC-SA licence. This newspaper is not available for commercial use without the consent of Allied Press Ltd. For advice on reproduction of out-of-copyright material from this newspaper, please refer to the Copyright guide.