TO THE EDITOB. Sir, —William Samuel Lilly, a sincere Catholic and admirer of His Eminence, gives us in this book the mental characteristics of the Archbishop of Westminster. It is, indeed, a gMasi-confession of Catholic faith, political, philosophical, and religious. From it we see how clearly irreconcilable the church is to the world. " Education is the formation of the whole man—intellect, heart, will, character, mind, and soul.' How a man of Manning's! education can swallow so many absurdities is a mystery to me. " Theology is the keystone of all knowledge "; but from medireval theology good Lord deliver us ! "The tendency of metaphysics and science in England is to eliminate the supernatural and to limit the basis of philosophy to the span of Bense and experiment." Superstition is really the cause of this gross materialism. Wo cannot, however, " account for right and wrong without reference to God, the giver of the law." Manning's writings are replete with sophistry, research, piety, integrity, and _ devotion to what he conceives to be divine truth, a? interpreted by a eo-called infallible church, animated, or at least assumed to be animated, by tho perpetual presence of the Holy Ghost. In virtue of being tho mechanical abode of the Holy Spirit, " the church in every age is not only preserved from error, but enabled at times to declare the truth, the infallibility of the living church at this hour." Here is the divine certainty and authority of the church against error and infidelity, notwithstanding that successive councils have contradicted each other in their oracular utterances. Catholicism, unlike Protestantism, does not rest on historical basis, criticism, and the balance of probabilities, but on faith in a Divine Founder and a divine internal monitor. Tho universal church is the organ of tho Holy Ghost. It is, according to Manning, immutable in its doctrines, because it is sustained in every ago incorrupt, primitive, and changeless by the Spirit. Only the church can reform itself. Faith is anterior to revelation itself. "Scripture itself depends for its attestation upon this witness, which teaches us our faith, and that witness is divine." Is not this reasoning in a circle ? The church attests the Bible, and tiio Bible guarantees the church ! This is logic fit for the Otago University. The church is "the body, inhabited by the Holy Ghost, illuminated and guided by His light and voice." Ergo, she ia infallible! But how do we know this? Through the Bible ! And, pray, what is the church? A body of self-styled infallible ecclesiastics. Such a mechanical transmission of God'a Holy Spirit shocks common sense.and verily leads to atheism. Cardinal Manning's ' Book of Characteristics' is really an eyeopener. Coming, as it does, from a scholar andaprinoeofthe church, it carries authority in its train, for the book is really made up of extracts from the Cardinal's works. We now know what Catholicism really is, and what it means, from the mouth of one of its moat learned dignitaries. Tu es Petrus—thou art Peter. The Pope of Rome is Peter's vicar and God's vicegerent upon earth, the Head of tho tabernacle of the Holy Ghost, consequently His Holiness is infallible when he speaks ex cathedra. The editor of this book is, as we said, a genuine sou of the church, and a hearty admirer and even idolater of Dr Manning. It is a refreshing book for an educated Roman Catholic—l am, etc., J. G. S. Grant. Dunedin, May 17.
Permanent link to this item
'CARDINAL MANNING.', Evening Star, Issue 7911, 20 May 1889
'CARDINAL MANNING.' Evening Star, Issue 7911, 20 May 1889
Using This Item
Allied Press Ltd is the copyright owner for the Evening Star. You can reproduce in-copyright material from this newspaper for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons New Zealand BY-NC-SA licence. This newspaper is not available for commercial use without the consent of Allied Press Ltd. For advice on reproduction of out-of-copyright material from this newspaper, please refer to the Copyright guide.