TO THB KDITOB. SIR,—In the London ' Times' of March 23 there is a most interesting letter from Professor Goldwin Smith on ' The Commercial Relations between Canada and the United States.! As the letter is rather too long for insertion in your columns, and as we have heard a good deal lately about federation, perhaps you might find room lor the last part of his letter, giving the opinion of a most loyal Englishman on Canadian federation.—l am, etc., Francis Waddell. Dunedin, May 13. In every respect, except politically, the fusion of the two portions of the Engliah-speakiix? race on this'continent is almost complete. We even largely use the American currency, and American bank notes pasß in Ontario at par: whilst those of our own maritime provinces and Manitoba do not. I* is reasonable to suppose that in the end political union will follow, and that the English-speaking, population of North
America will some day become altogether one people Thero is at least one loyal Englishman who believes that England will be the gainer by that consummation; that having irrecoverably lost all real power hero, and having nothing left but liabilities and dinger, she would be fortunate in exchanging these for a secure and lasting friendship with the whole continent. That Canadian society can by the presence of a representative monarchy with his court, or by d ; stributing a few baronetcies and knighthoods, be mvla otherwise than democratic must, to eve*yone who knows Canada, appear the fondest of dreams. But, as I have before said, the belief that palitical union is imminent, so that a meie fUcal change would bring it about-, does not fe<m to me to be well founded. All the Canadian politicians, for vety obvious reasons, !>!■: assinst it, and it would he very difficult fo. the people (even if they were so inclined) to move without the piliticianc The Americans, saving a few frenzied "tail-twisters," are as far as possible from desiring to force us into the Vnion. They are indifferent, if not averse, to the extension of territory, and they know that they would be storing up trouble for themselves by annexing five millions of unwilling and dissatisfied citizens. Of the American politicians many, perhaps most, are at least as much afraid of the disturbance which the Canadian vote might produoa in the balance of parties as they are ambitious of national aggrandizement. A Republican Senator told me in plain terms that he would bo opposed to the reception of Canada into the Union, because Canada would vote democratic Communities are not easily lifted out of tha ruts in which they have for tome time run. Apart, therefore, from the actual pressure on Canada of commercial or actual war, it seems to me that the day of political union with the American Republic, though sure to come, may be distant. In the meantime Canada must have access to her natural matket, that is the United States.—Yours faithfully, Goldwin Smith. Toronto, March 11.
Permanent link to this item
IMPERIAL FEDERATION., Evening Star, Issue 7905, 13 May 1889
IMPERIAL FEDERATION. Evening Star, Issue 7905, 13 May 1889
Using This Item
Allied Press Ltd is the copyright owner for the Evening Star. You can reproduce in-copyright material from this newspaper for non-commercial use under a Creative Commons New Zealand BY-NC-SA licence. This newspaper is not available for commercial use without the consent of Allied Press Ltd. For advice on reproduction of out-of-copyright material from this newspaper, please refer to the Copyright guide.