Article image
Article image
Article image
This article displays in one automatically-generated column. View the full page to see article in its original form.


Deolded'y the most sensitive person of whom wo ("Albany Law Journal") have ever heard ig I}r Thwing, of the New York Mediao-Legal Society. If we are to oreditthia gentleman's own words/he is In favor of putting to death people mortally wounded, although unconscious of pain, iH their writhings ond groaninge are troublesome to him as the attending phyßlolan In a recent paper entitled "Batb«*n>Bia m A rticulio Mortis," he tells about an aged lady, a relation of his, who, m his opinion, ought to have died " within a day or two," bat was for five days speechless, comatOße, and unconscious, 81 id evidently doomed to die — sometime* " The reality of suffering I could not admit," says the dootor frankly, *• bat the appearance of it m actions purely reflex was painful to me. As her only surviving kinsman, I took the responsibility of administering a mild anesthetic" Presently his soul grew stronger, ani he took the responsibility of causing her to inhale a mixture of ohloroform and sulpliurio ether, which onused her deuth ia a quarter of an hour. At the same meeting, Dr Olark Bell told about a child two years old suffering from a disease from which there was no apparent chance of its recovery " Eminent physicians deoided that the child mutst die " Dr Bell assented 80 they tried to kill jr with morphlie, but the' obstinate lit:le villuln would not die to oxder. It lived for s veral woeks. It died In the end of marasmus. A discussion by the eooiety Jndioated that a majority agreed m disapproving of this sort of practice. Verily the dootors are a (|U9«r Jgt — r^iliiog 0$ q|4 wom« R » n d little

babies beforo ihoir t;tne to vt rify their pred otiona and save :heir sensibility, and fighting hard to keep life m those murderous demons [referring here to the nutneroHs instances m whioh American doctors support ihe plea of emotional ineanity] who hare will enough to kill their fellow creature* and not strength of miad enough to refrain from doing it«

This article text was automatically generated and may include errors. View the full page to see article in its original form.
Permanent link to this item

Bibliographic details

IS IT MURDER?, Ashburton Guardian, Volume VII, Issue 2169, 10 July 1889

Word Count

IS IT MURDER? Ashburton Guardian, Volume VII, Issue 2169, 10 July 1889